« "Since then the event venue has been for sale to the highest bidder." | Main | "I wouldn't mind that." »

Golf Digest Best New 2007

bestnewcourses_470.jpgNow posted at GolfDigest.com, Jack Nicklaus and Tom Doak's Sebonack takes the private category.

The Best New Public With Hot Beverage Cart Girls Over $75 goes to Virginia's Highland Course at Primland by Donald Steel and Martin Ebert.

Best New Public Where You Might Have To Change Shoes In The Parking Lot Under $75 goes to another Virginia course, Ed Carton's Spring Creek.

The Best New Public Remodel, Lester George's restoration of The Greenbrier, beats out in stunning fifth place position, the horrid Industry Hills, aka Misery Hills, oh, wait, it's been rebranded as Industry HIlls GC at Pacific Palms Resort. I think the rebranding put it in the top 5.

Best New Private Remodel, goes to Gil Hanse, Brad Faxon and Jim Wagner for their revitalization of TPC Boston, edging out Rees Jones remodels of Bellerive and Atlanta Athletic Club as well as Jack Nicklaus's work at Ohio State.

And Best New Canadian goes to Muskoka Bay by Doug Carrick.

Stephen Szurlej's exclusive photos of the winners are posted, but other than the aerials of Sebonack I wouldn't waste your time unless you want to see a bunch of TPC Boston ground views from behind greens guarded by lakes. Not as horrific as his photo of Rustic Canyon when it won, which actually was taken by a blind ground squirrel. However, considering how easy the two courses are to photograph (I know, I'm biased) and considering the landscape photography work of folks like Lambrecht, Dost, Brown, the Henebry's, Cuban, Furore and Scalletti, Golf Digest should farm this assignment out.

While not award winning, at least some of these images give you a sense of why TPC Boston edged out some tough competition. 

Posted on Dec 4, 2007 at 09:01AM by Registered CommenterGeoff in , , | Comments19 Comments

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (19)

It seems like a fairly week year, Sebonack stands out from the rest. Hard to believe Liberty National made the list. C&C's Colorado Golf Club maybe is a bit low to be 5th?
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterJSS
Another collaboration award for Nicklaus Design. Have they won any significant design accolades on their own?
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterCMA
Best New Public Remodel? Aren't these categories getting a bit ridiculous.

12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterCMA
$300 in Biloxi Mississippi?
Yikes

2. FALLEN OAK • Saucier, Miss. • Yards 7,487 • Par 72 • Fee: $300 • Tom Fazio • 877-805-4657 • fallenoak.com
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterAl
what about chambers bay?
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterTuco Ramirez
Tuco, Chambers Bay didn't open in the window of time specified by GD. It'll be up for consideration for next year's list.
12.4.2007 | Unregistered Commentersodface
Fallen Oak at $300 does seem expensive except that the club is owned by Beau Rivage who's owner is MGM/Mirage which also owns Shadow Creek. The web site looks impressive. Panelists (and not just Golf Digest) like to be pampered so I'm surprised it didn't finish higher?
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterTivo
"Best New Public Remodel? Aren't these categories getting a bit ridiculous?" -- CMA

This may be to keep the architects happy, because a lot of them aren't doing any new courses these days.

I'll say this -- with the reversal of the golf boom, the competition for the next few years won't be as heavy as it was during the 1990s, when the Best News were chosen from a pool of about 500 courses each year.

Ar the rate we're going, in 2010 we may see less than 200 new courses open.



12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterFour-putt
4 p
I think Golf Digest is considering yet another category, best course that closed last year.
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterLynn S.
There's significantly more panelists nowadays, too. Aren't there?

12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterAdam Clayman
So what is the green fee at the "affordable public course Spring Creek?" The approaches are walked mowed!
12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterLynn S.
4-putt

2006 - last year there were about 110 new courses.
2007 - This year probably less around 100.
2008 - Next year even less maybe 80?

12.4.2007 | Unregistered CommenterMN
Muskoka Bay in Canada. Nobody has heard of it. Probably another HIGH PRICED track. Who cares ???
12.5.2007 | Unregistered CommenterJohn Sullivan
Adam - actually they are scaling back the panelists.
12.5.2007 | Unregistered Commenterbutler cabin
Public remodel? Doesn't the public remodel every course, every day, due to high traffic?
12.5.2007 | Unregistered CommenterRonald Montesano
And Fallen Oak is worth every penny, folks. The best greens I've ever putted on -- period.

Picture Shadow Creek of the Southeast... on a better plot of land... at the edge of a national forest... with better greens... and you've got Fallen Oak.
'Muskoka Bay in Canada. Nobody has heard of it. Probably another HIGH PRICED track. Who cares ???'
Uh, Canadians do.
I think it listed the green fee at 155, which for Muskoka (summer vacation area) is pretty good.
Doug Carrick, the architect, is my local fave. His Osprey Valley Heathlands is a great course, a great walk and great value. I've probably played it 200 times and it's never grown old. If you're ever in the Toronto area give it a go.
12.5.2007 | Unregistered CommenterDBH
I strongly recommend playing any Tom Doak course you can.
MN --

"2006 - last year there were about 110 new courses.
2007 - This year probably less around 100.
2008 - Next year even less maybe 80?"

Where did you get these stats? The NGF stopped releasing the number of new openings in 2004, with 105.5 18-hole equivalents and a forecast of 150-160 for 2005. (Why is it in so love with lumping the numbers into 18-hole equivalents? But I digress.)

But that's where it ended, cementing my statement that the NGF is nothing more than a cheerleader for golf, a windsock. If it is truly clocking the industry as it claims, why not continue reporting the numbers, even if they're declining?

4p
12.5.2007 | Unregistered CommenterFour-putt

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.