"The golf establishment, especially in the United States, is full of venal, haunted little men--players, executives, sportswriters, broadcasters"
I'm reluctant to link the Matthew DeBord-authored Huffington Post piece that reader Rick sent, but it's so uninformed and off base that I just can't resist. The topic? The media and white men running the game of golf are to blame for Michelle Wie's 2006-2008 doldrums. (Yes, it's a timely piece, too!)
Why would golf do this to its most bankable star since Tiger Woods? Simple: She's a woman in a sport full of men who never stop being threatened. The golf establishment, especially in the United States, is full of venal, haunted little men--players, executives, sportswriters, broadcasters--who pledge allegiance to the spirit and dignity of an ancient Scottish game, but who in truth want to dismiss anything that disrupts their once-comfortable lock on the sport.
If only the golf establishment was an interesting as he suggests.
That said, we know the situation is quite the opposite in two ways. First, that the establishment was most definitely hoping (and continues to pray) she succeeds so they can profit off her success. And two, her parents have received the harsh treatment for career mismanagement and oddball things like wanting to live in her dorm and hanging with her on campus.
It's been forgotten now, but Tiger was assailed when he first arrived.
That's right, he was a tad rough around the edges and his dad made some ludicrous suggestions that, well, turned out to be about right.
Some called his epic 1997 Masters win a fluke.
Riiiiiggggghhhhhtttt!
Others suggested that he had been given unfair advantages by being allowed to skip the PGA Tour's qualifying school.
Maybe in a barber shop in Indonesia? Because after all he skipped Q-school because he made enough money to earn his card.
But over the ensuing years, through sheer brilliance, Woods wore down his critics. By the time he won the 2008 U.S. Open, limping through a Monday playoff on what was effectively a broken leg, all naysaying had been vanquished.
Yep, not until Torrey Pines in '08 had the naysayers been vanquished!
Arianna, this is embarrassing. Wait, there's more?
Michelle Wie had the potential to be bigger than the game and to provide women's golf with the worldwide explosion in popularity that it needs.
And last I heard, no one doubts that is still possible. I guess except DeBord?
But the best possible time for that to happen was two or three years ago, before she was buried under an avalanche of negativity and slumped. She's back now, and she seems like a more mature person and more complete player. But opportunity lost is still opportunity lost. And if women's golf continues to falter, golf will only have itself and its ridiculous, petty culture to blame. Wie was, and to a degree, still is the future. Her ascent was Tiger Woods crossed with the Williams sisters. Her decline was troubling. Her comeback is critical.
Well we agree that her "comeback" from brilliant talent is critical.
























Wednesday, November 11, 2009 at 03:27 PM
Reader Comments (15)
What DeBord really meant to write was, "Wie, by contrast, has been worn down by the ridiculous expectations of IMG and the absolute, total, and perfect obtuseness of her parents." Other than that, he is still full of crap and reminds me why I gave up on Slate shortly after Weisberg became editor. BTW, this is an embarrassment to Arianna, too. Not that we should expect her to know a thing about the Game.
thusgone, no need to worry about RedState chiming in. They have their hands full with Bible Spice's "book" coming out soon. For the time being anyway.
Thank you, Rick, and Geoff, for sharing.
This guys writes something that is completely wrong and since it gets published people will read it. If these readers are not in the know, they might believe it. And this will hurt the game of golf.
Someone writes a complete and utter false story that could hurt the game of golf and he gets away with it. This is not right!
She's going to school as well. All things considered, it's a wonder she's stayed together mentally as well as she has. I'm for one am rooting for her....for her success in winning events would validate her ability and restore her confidence.
1. Michelle's desire to be a student first and a golfer second. To achieve what was missed would have required her to quit school and golf full time. In contrast to the decision to turn pro, I think this decision to follow her dream was a good one.
2. The LPGA. Their failure to offer Wie additional events for top 10 finishes (ala the PGAT) gave her little opportunity to compete against women.
2 1/2. David Leadbetter. He ruined a beautiful swing in an effort to achieve ???
If Tiger had holed his drive on the 18th at Augusta on Sunday to win the 1997 Masters by one, I would probably consider that a fluke. The author seems to forget that Tiger won by 12 strokes and I don't remember anyone calling it a fluke. In fact I just remember everyone being amazed at a great talent.