Sunday
Jan212007
"You should invite her to the next member-guest competition at your home club and she might actually win something."
Thanks to reader Phillip for catching Butch Harmon's Michelle Wie-related comments to Mark Reason in the Sunday Telegraph.
Harmon's brutally honest, but it's hard to argue with what he has to say.
"The whole thing is absolutely ridiculous," he says. "Michelle has regressed. She is worse now at 17 than she was at 14. To continue telling us that she is getting better by playing with the men is an insult. She says it's a learning experience. What is she learning by finishing last? It's hurting her mentally.
"She should go play with the women and dominate that competition first. But the whole Michelle Wie camp is about money. The biggest difference between Earl [Woods, the father of Tiger] and BJ [Wie, Michelle's dad] is that Earl didn't worry about money. He knew it was more important for Tiger to learn to win and then the money would take care of itself. But Michelle Wie wins nothing.
"You should invite her to the next member-guest competition at your home club and she might actually win something because what's going on now is ridiculous. And it's not good for the game of golf."





















Sunday, January 21, 2007 at 08:17 PM
Reader Comments (8)
Hopefully, my club has become a bit more enlightened about this kind of thing than they used to be. About ten years ago I tried to invite the current ladies USGA Mid-Amateur champion and many times Curtis Cupper to this annual member/guest and the cavemen on the committee actually turned me down. Can you believe that??
The fact that there was no actual rule that the tournament was only for men wasn't even the thing that pissed me off about them turning me down. For about 75 years they'd obviously just been assuming that a member couldn't invite a female guest.
Frankly, even though they knew we would've won, that wasn't the thing that disturbed them, in my opinion. It was that I told them that she would outdrive about 98% of them from the championship tees which she would have done. I saw her do that kind of thing on more than one occassion.
So, who do I get in touch with to invite Michelle as my AJDP member/guest partner---would it be Michelle herself or BJ?
As for Stanford, she won't be playing any college golf there, obviously. Which is too bad. A year and a half ago, she was creating a genuine, honest-to-gosh story in golf by moving through the match play rounds of the USGA APL, beating guys who were the senior captains of their college golf teams.
I agree that this spectacle is not good for golf, and particularly bad if we initiate a whole new era of teenage burnouts contrived on the Team Wie model.