Latest From GolfDigest.com
Latest From The Loop
Twitter
Feedblitz
To Get GeoffShackelford.com Posts Delivered To Your Inbox Enter Email Address Below:


Powered by FeedBlitz
Books
  • Lines of Charm: Brilliant And Irreverent Quotes, Notes, And Anecdotes from Golf's Golden Age Architects
    Lines of Charm: Brilliant And Irreverent Quotes, Notes, And Anecdotes from Golf's Golden Age Architects
  • The Future of Golf: How Golf Lost Its Way and How to Get It Back
    The Future of Golf: How Golf Lost Its Way and How to Get It Back
    by Geoff Shackelford
  • Grounds for Golf: The History and Fundamentals of Golf Course Design
    Grounds for Golf: The History and Fundamentals of Golf Course Design
    by Geoff Shackelford
  • The Art of Golf Design
    The Art of Golf Design
    by Michael Miller, Geoff Shackelford
  • Alister MacKenzie's Cypress Point Club
    Alister MacKenzie's Cypress Point Club
    by Geoff Shackelford
  • The Golden Age of Golf Design
    The Golden Age of Golf Design
    by Geoff Shackelford
  • The Good Doctor Returns: A Novel
    The Good Doctor Returns: A Novel
    by Geoff Shackelford
  • Masters of the Links: Essays on the Art of Golf and Course Design
    Masters of the Links: Essays on the Art of Golf and Course Design
  • The Captain: George C. Thomas Jr. and His Golf Architecture
    The Captain: George C. Thomas Jr. and His Golf Architecture
    by Geoff Shackelford
Current Reading
  • The Early Days of Pinehurst
    The Early Days of Pinehurst
    by Chris Buie
  • Arnie, Seve, and a Fleck of Golf History: Heroes, Underdogs, Courses, and Championships
    Arnie, Seve, and a Fleck of Golf History: Heroes, Underdogs, Courses, and Championships
    by Bill Fields
  • The Magnificent Masters: Jack Nicklaus, Johnny Miller, Tom Weiskopf, and the 1975 Cliffhanger at Augusta
    The Magnificent Masters: Jack Nicklaus, Johnny Miller, Tom Weiskopf, and the 1975 Cliffhanger at Augusta
    by Gil Capps
  • His Ownself: A Semi-Memoir
    His Ownself: A Semi-Memoir
    by Dan Jenkins
  • Professional Golf 2014: The Complete Media, Fan and Fantasy Guide
    Professional Golf 2014: The Complete Media, Fan and Fantasy Guide
    by Daniel Wexler
Classics
  • Golf Architecture in America: Its Strategy and Construction
    Golf Architecture in America: Its Strategy and Construction
    by Geo. C. Thomas
  • The Course Beautiful : A Collection of Original Articles and Photographs on Golf Course Design
    The Course Beautiful : A Collection of Original Articles and Photographs on Golf Course Design
    Treewolf Prod
  • Reminiscences Of The Links
    Reminiscences Of The Links
    by Albert Warren Tillinghast, Richard C. Wolffe, Robert S. Trebus, Stuart F. Wolffe
  • Gleanings from the Wayside
    Gleanings from the Wayside
    by Albert Warren Tillinghast
  • Planet Golf USA: The Definitive Reference to Great Golf Courses in America
    Planet Golf USA: The Definitive Reference to Great Golf Courses in America
    by Darius Oliver
  • Planet Golf: The Definitive Reference to Great Golf Courses Outside the United States of America
    Planet Golf: The Definitive Reference to Great Golf Courses Outside the United States of America
    by Darius Oliver
Writing And Videos
« Old Course Joins Twitter, Gets #savetheoldcourse Hashtag, UK Press Slowly Begins To Notice | Main | Quick PGA Tour & LPGA Tour Q-School's Primer »
Monday
Nov262012

The R&A's Changes To St. Andrews That Were Not Approved

Reader Steve Scott says the St. Andrews Links Trust actually rejected several Old Course modifications proposed by architects Martin Hawtree and Peter Dawson before approving plans to renovate the planet's most revered golf course.

Thanks to well-placed sources combing the trash cans of St. Andrews, I was able to piece together a copy of the rejected changes after they had been destroyed. The Links Trust does not do its document shredding by machine but instead turn the papers over to a retired club secretary who enjoys sharpening his poultry shears on the town's most important documents.

So I've transcribed the shredded pieces that were overnighted to me and posted the Art Department's acquisition of two architectural renderings that were rejected. Enjoy!

Proposed Changes To The Old Course For Future Consideration

- Eliminate 17th fairway. The efforts to narrow this hole in recent years have failed to lift the scoring average to hoped-for heights. Therefore, your Old Course consulting architects recommend complete elimination of the short grass fairway cut until the putting surface. The architect sees a fine marketing angle in this change as well: an homage to the late Seve Ballesteros, who often advocated eliminating fairways altogether and who celebrated his finest moment at the Road hole. Check. Mate.

Architect rendering of the Road hole work appears, well, complicated and confusing. (Click to enlarge)- Raise the Road hole stone wall six inches.
Though this is a major and costly undertaking to physically lift a wall that has stood for centuries, the architects feel strongly that too many poorly hit shots end up near its base, creating regrettably memorable situations like the one Tom Watson faced in 1984 or the heroic recovery of Miguel Angel Jimenez in 2010 which gave the unfortunate impression that elite players have skill. By raising the wall a mere six inches, this will allow balls overshooting the 17th green to roll out of bounds, causing more two-stroke penalties whilst restoring a necessary premium on accuracy current lacking due to the original wall structure that once saved Mary Queen of Scots from a disastrous quintuple bogey.

- Renovate all bunker floors. While this is part of the ongoing sod wall rebuilding that adds such a clean, refined and utterly EA Sports-worthy look to the Old Course, the architect recommends that all bunker floors be rebuilt and pitched toward the faces of the sand. This will ensure more balls end up unplayable, thus stiffening the hazard defenses while restoring a premium on accuracy lost since players are not hitting the ball any longer than they did ten years ago.

- Convert the Eden into a Redan. The par-3 11th green has become too difficult and unwieldy as modern green speeds restrict the R&A to only a small area for Open Championship hole locations. While some would suggest a slower green speed could resolve the matter, good sense tells us that it would be far more difficult, expensive and risky to completely renovate the green complex while paying long overdue homage to North Berwick’s Redan. Therefore, we see the only course of action as complete renovation. Though some will protest that this much-copied hole has been the site of so many important moments in golf history, who is to say that a sporty reverse-Redan would not bring as much joy to the next four centuries of golfers as the current Eden has over the previous 400 years? (Assuming, of course, that the green doesn’t wash away due to rising sea levels, in which case your architects believe Redan is more easily suited to conversion to an island green one-shotter.)

Proposed rendering of the Eden's conversion to a Redan that was rejected (Click image to enlarge) - Shift the Principal’s Nose.  This acute spur formation of three bunkers amidst the 16th fairways blocks Old Course Hotel views for the Ian Woosnam demographic. The nose currently sports two “nostril” bunkers in such a way that they are blind to the player in the fairway playing to the green. The architect feels this kind of deception has passed the game by and could be offensive to St. Andrews guests from around the world. In place of the Principal’s Nose, we would shave and re-shape this acute formation into something more closely resembling Kate Middleton's nose.

- Rocca-proof the Valley of Sin, 18th hole. As with the pesky swale we plan to fill-in on the 7th fairway, this acute dip formation would drain better with a catch basin and sump. We would also recommend converting this problematic formation into fescue rough similar to the wonderful rough cultivated on the 17th hole. Such a change to four inch grass would prevent players from putting balls onto the green when in this location, as Constantino Rocca did in such regrettable fashion back when players hit the ball the same distance they do today. The Links Trust might also consider planting a couple of extra spindly gorse bushes in the base of the Sin to hide the catch basin. This would also provide a long term solution to the non-problem of players not hitting the ball any longer than they did ten years ago, just as the R&A’s research does not confirm.

PrintView Printer Friendly Version

EmailEmail Article to Friend

Reader Comments (10)

Very amusing, Geoff. You must have a great deal of time on your hands...maybe I could suggest you get out more?

FYI, the only one they rejected they were willing to tell me about was a proposal for an additional bunker in the left half of the sixth fairway, considered to be overkill. But there were others, I was assured.
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterSteve Scott
Brillant!!! Only error was leaving off the joint Rees/Faz attribution next to Dawsons.
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterTravis Bickle
How about eliminating the double fairways with a row of Georgia pines?
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterJim
What?! Nothing about Green-to-Tee mowing patterns Mr Geoff?
11.27.2012 | Unregistered Commenterjohnnycz
Interesting, nothing about replacing the silly old stone bridge with a nice new colored poly carbonate single span.
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterB Jennings
Why not just plant trees?
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterAdam Clayman
Rough? In front of a links green? <fainting>
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterThe O
What would also make a wonderful addition would be to turn the road to the sea crossing the 1st and 18th fairway into one of those moving walkways like they have in airports. (Feaux stone walls on either side could hide the moving handrails.) Then Americans could aim hyrbids at moving apple-cheeked youth like shooting ducks at a pinball arcade. Think of the added extra shots to all scorecards.

Also, how about asking Trump to design a waterfall coming out of the R&A front door and under the walkway behind the first tee? This would certainly be an improvement on the current drivel coming out of that building.
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterRLL
Its funny how older golf institutions are treated like some type of holy religion ! The old course wasn't even there for most of the planet's history, and won't survive the coming rise in sea levels either.
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterTom
Surprised Ernie wasn't brought in to help following his success at Wentworth.
11.27.2012 | Unregistered CommenterStord

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.