Phony Finish

Add Peter Kostis to the list of those underwhelmed by Tim Finchem's announced intentions to fix the Tour schedule. He raises several points not addressed in other columns and offers this extreme idea, sounds much closer to something the Tour should consider to make this so-called "playoff" dramatic instead of a rich-get-rich pyramid scheme:

...if you really want to create some excitement, play the FedEx Cup finale tournaments with a $10 million purse—winner takes all.

You have to figure that if the Tour can't convince players to do something semi-radical at The International (daily cuts, start from scratch Sunday), it's going to be tough to convince the players that FedEx Cup will only work with something bold and brash. And this is why the FedEx Cup concept will continue to receive nothing but yawns and "why?"

Hawkins on Tour TV Deal

Golf World's John Hawkins weighs in on the proposed 2007 concept for the Tour. He's mostly celebratory, so much so that the Commish will want to order reprints. But the story is loaded with mini-bombshells and interesting anecdotes may infuriate the rank-and-file player while creating new questions about how the framework of the schedule was put together.

With considerable help from the title sponsor, the FedEx Cup will offer a whopping $38 million payoff to the 30 players who make it to the Tour Championship, a source told Golf World. About 25 percent of that will go to the winner -- unofficial money likely to come in the form of a contribution to the players' retirement funds.

Hawkins will get a wine and cheese basket from the Commissioner for this line:

Though it may never rival the major championships in terms of relevance or do much to determine a Player of the Year, the four-week playoff series should resolve the tours late-season issues and bolster Finchem's bargaining power when he meets with the networks to negotiate the upcoming television contract, a process that is expected to begin this week.

Here's the part that may have the rank and file asking more questions:

It's hard to imagine a scenario where fewer than the top 70 would advance into the playoffs. Although the tour has developed a reputation in recent years for disregarding the best interests of its middle class, the FedEx Cup series will market opportunity -- the idea that No. 78 in the standings could get hot, play great golf under immense pressure and walk off with the $10 million. In a manner of speaking, he'll have earned it. "It will probably be like NASCAR, where it's hard to move up [in the Nextel Cup]," Woods surmised. "The research says 80 percent of the time, the winner comes out of the top five [in the standings]."

And this really caught my eye:

"There are going to be two sides to this," said IMG's Mark Steinberg, Woods' agent and a key player in the shaping of the tour's revisions. "A player who has a dominant year may get passed because of the reset. Having said that, a player who had a good year but not a great one will have a chance to make it great in the final month."

Tiger's agent was a "key player" in shaping the revisions? Hmmm. He also, amazingly, was complimentary:

In that sense, Finchem didn't exactly pull a rabbit out of his hat, but he didn't produce a goat, either. "I think Tim and Ed [tour executive VP Moorhouse] have done a hell of a job in creating a new system," Steinberg said. "They've done a great job of salvaging what could have been a very difficult situation."

Uh, they haven't inked any deals yet.

The television networks may be very willing to fork over a dollar total close to (or more than) the nearly $1 billion it paid to telecast the tour four years ago, but the long-term relationship between pro golf and TV could be irreparably harmed if Finchem doesn't deliver a series of tournaments that feature all the game's top-ranked players.
"It's a step in the right direction," ESPN's Wildhack said. "Player participation is what drives ratings. The three guys that make the ratings are Woods, Mickelson and John Daly."

Then Hawkins drops this, which doesn't exactly make the ESPN guy look too good.

Last month's WGC-American Express Championship featured a near-perfect competitive scenario on Sunday afternoon: Woods vs. Daly in a playoff televised by ABC, whose parent company, Disney, also owns ESPN and has an endorsement deal with Woods. Despite a marquee leader board (Sergio Garcia and Colin Montgomerie also were in contention), the WGC emblem and the Woods-Daly showdown, the final round ranked 21st in sports programming shown on national TV that weekend.

Ferguson On Augusta Changes

masterslogo.jpegDid I miss a media day? Now AP's Doug Ferguson weighs in from Augusta (these guys must know a lot of members!) and reports on the "attempt to restore the rhythm and shot value the way Bobby Jones and Alister MacKenzie designed it."

Rhythm?

Ferguson employed the Bobby Jones quote describing what the greatest of them all expected players to hit into No. 4 from then until eternity.

Jones gave Sports Illustrated a hole-by-hole description in 1959 and said of the par-3 fourth, ''The shot is usually a strong iron, or even a 4- or 3-wood.''

Here's what Jones wrote:

This hole can be varied a great deal, depending on the use of the back tee or the rear portion of the forward tee. From the back tee the shot is usually a strong iron or even a four or three wood.

In other words, he expected both tees to be used to create the day-to-day variety that he loved in St. Andrews (and wrote about extensively). Hopefully the committee will do the same this year.

Regarding the first hole, Ferguson writes: 

The tee box has been moved back about 20 yards to make the hole play 455 yards, although change at Augusta National is not all about length.

The eye-opener is that cavernous bunker down the right side, where a finger of turf now dips into the sand and creates the appearance of a double bunker. Balls rarely will be in the middle of the sand, allowing for a routine escape; now there will be steep lips in the way.

Here's what Jones wrote about No. 1:

This hole can be played straight away from tee to green, although the fairway does expand on the right as it approaches the green. Ordinarily, the fairway bunker on the right presents no problem for the tournament player. With a heavy wind against, however, as often happens, a half-hit tee shot may catch this bunker.

He went on to write mostly about the strategy of the green complex, which thankfully retains its brilliance today (until Tom Fazio convinces Hootie he can reproduce it 10 yards back and 30 to the right.

But no mention from Jones of teeing off from Butler Cabin if necessary to get the bunker in play. And nothing about adding bunker tongues to discourage those heroic recovery shots. In fact, in the chapter on Augusta he noted:

...the elimination of purely punitive hazards provides an opportunity for the player to retrieve his situation by an exceptional second shot. A course which is constructed with these principles in view must be interesting, because it will offer problems which a man may attempt, according to his ability.

Those democratic golf values are so last century Bobby!

Ferguson lets Dow Finsterwald sum up what the changes are really about.

Augusta National is longer and harder than ever. Players hit the ball longer and better than ever.

''Their ability is so marvelous,'' [Dow] Finsterwald said. ''It's not that they're so much longer, they're straighter. And there are more good putters than there were. So I don't think the test has changed. But players have risen to the changes. But the scores stay pretty much in the ballpark, don't they?''

Two More '07 Skeptics

The normally jovial Kraig Kann sounds skeptical in posing ten questions about the proposed 2007 Tour concept.

And Seth Soffian reports that Greg Norman says what a lot of writers have come close to saying:

"The PGA Tour plays things close to the chest," said Norman, taking a not-so-veiled shot at Finchem, who offered only a framework for the proposed schedule changes last week after a year of speculation.

"You don't really know what's going on until Finchem decides to say something, and then when he says something, he really doesn't tell you anyway. If you're going to make an announcement, make an announcement and tell the world what's going on."
But see Greg, if you make an announcement without really saying anything, and no one likes the sound of the announcment,  then you can say you never really made such an announcement!

Floggers Rule?

FlogGolf2.jpgOh no, not more stats! Sorry, but it's fun to see how flogging is the way to play the PGA Tour. (For you newcomers to this site's rantings, flogging is the bomb it out there and worry about the consequences later. You can read more about it here and here.)

Flogging has become such a big part of the sport that the graphics department here at gs.com developed a logo.

Anyhow, here is a list of the top 30 money winners, with their driving distance rank followed by their driving accuracy rank. I've included where Padraig Harrington would have ranked if he had enough rounds to qualify for the final statistic lists.

Rank    Player      Dist       Acc
1        Tiger Woods          1              188
2        Vijay Singh            16            147
3        Phil Mickelson        26            161
4        Jim Furyk             170            31
5        David Toms           107            54
6        Kenny Perry             9             88
7        Chris DiMarco         164          122

8        Retief Goosen         44           157
9        Bart Bryant            147            6
10      Sergio Garcia          10           153
11      Fred Funk              197             2
12      Justin Leonard       128            74
13      Davis Love III            8           165
14      P. Harrington          54*          188*
15      Adam Scott             23           175
16      Scott Verplank         59            9
17      Luke Donald           135           75
18      Sean O'Hair             23           127
19      Ben Crane               61           182
20      Chad Campbell        52           122
21      Tim Clark               140          58
22      Billy Mayfair            103          21
23      Stuart Appleby         19           155
24      Ted Purdy                45           88
25      Mark Calcavecchia    91           49
26      Olin Browne             173          4
27      Brandt Jobe              11          178
28      Tim Herron              65           122
29      Charles Howell III     56          170
30      Lucas Glover            12           138

Top 30 Average:  70th in Distance, 105th in Accuracy

Top 10 Average:  69th in Distance,  111th in Accuracy

Tiger in China

Sounds like Tiger had a lot of people taking pictures of him today.

Q. There were a lot of cameras going off on the course; how big of a distraction was that to you?

TIGER WOODS: It was a little bit of a distraction certainly, but hey, you know, golf they are not used to seeing golf here, so we can understand it. But they are pretty respectful. They felt bad. They don't know when to take the pictures and once you learn, they get better.

 

Haven't these people seen what Stevie will do to a camera?

They should just hand out a little leaflet at the entrance with a picture of Stevie chucking (gosh I miss that word) a Nikon into a lake. That'll teach them to leave their cameras at home.

Rude On Western Open

Jeff Rude on the proposed disaster known as the Western Open moving to September:

Cog Hill owner Frank Jemsek has given his course to the Tour annually for no charge — that's right, no site fee — and this is what he gets? A sharp stick in the eye? Right after he meets with architect Rees Jones with the idea of face-lifting the course?Doesn't seem quite fair.

Well, that's what you get for hiring Rees. Oh wait, you meant, oh I gotcha. Sorry. My bad.

You want to rotate the Western around to four courses, then let's do it in Chicago. Knock on the doors of Medinah, Olympia Fields, Butler National and others. Get three courses to rotate with Cog Hill. If those clubs don't step up, keep going down the wealthy list.

I challenge the Tour and the membership of those clubs to step up and keep a Tour event in Chicago every year. I'm looking for someone with soul.

Jeff, you meant, $oul.

Tour's Longest Drive Stat

PGA Tour logo.jpgNot a big fan here of the PGA Tour's "longest drive" stat since Kapalua, Colorado and cart paths skew the numbers. Still, I found these numbers interesting in light of the USGA/R&A's 2002 "any further significant increases in hitting distances at the highest level are undesirable" benchmark:

1992 PGA Tour Longest Drive Stat
0 drives over 400 yards
3 at 350 yards or higher

1993
0 drives over 400 yards
18 over 350 yards

1994
0 drives over 400 yards
4 over 350 yards

1995
0 drives over 400 yards
22 over 350 yards

1996
0 drives over 400 yards
13 over 350 yards

Bored yet? Hang in there.

1997
0 drives over 400 yards
28 over 350 yards

1998
5 drives over 400 yards
46 over 350 yards

1999
1 drives over 400 yards
112 over 350 yards

2000
0 drives over 400 yards
42 over 350 yards

2001
1 over 400 yards
79 over 350 yards

2002
1 over 400 yards
80 over 350 yards

2003
1 over 400 yards
118 over 350 yards

2004
32 over 400 yards
210 over 350 yards

2005
19 over 400 yards
978 over 350 (but list stops at 357!)

Okay, before you go what the $%*& (like I did), consider this: in 2005, the Tour apparently started using ShotLink for the longest drive stat. So instead of taking the long drives from the two measuring holes, 2005 encompasses all of the drives hit. Still, you are probably talking about a significant number of drives over 350 yards hit in 2005. (I've asked for the number from the Tour, as well as the possibility of finding out the tally from the two measuring holes only.)

For another comparison that shows just how much those work out programs and brick hard fairways are compensating for the lousy clubs and balls, the Nationwide numbers still just worked off of two measuring holes in 2005:

2002
3 drives over 400 yards
125 over 350 yards

2003
9 drives over 400 yards
199 over 350 yards

2004
4 drives over 400 yards
138 over 350 yards

2005
4 drives over 400 yards
303 over 350 yards

Nearly double the number of tee shots over 350 yards since 2002 when the line was drawn?  

Something's going on. Either we're talking about optimization of launch conditions, better workout programs, widespread use of performance enhancing drugs, really firm fairways, or, did I mention optimization launch conditions?