Thank You For Not Smoking
/No more smoking on San Francisco city courses...there goes John Daly's changes of being a Captain's pick for the 2009 President's Cup?
It’s back!
Twenty years later Tatra Press has kindly allowed me to bring back Grounds For Golf now that golf architecture is of more interest to the masses. A new Introduction looks at what’s driven the interest growth and two new chapters I had a blast adding (plus a few edits to keep things up-to-date).
The Amazon purchase page for the book arriving June 15, 2026.
No more smoking on San Francisco city courses...there goes John Daly's changes of being a Captain's pick for the 2009 President's Cup?
Bill Fields in this Golf World Masters preview, writing about the course changes:
It is almost as if Wimbledon traded grass for clay and reduced the service box by half. Legends are vexed and current competitiors are wary.And he has this quote from Pete Dye, who clearly has not read The Spirit of St. Andrews in a while:
Architect Pete Dye, who has had to re-work a number of his designs to accommodate the distances top golfers are hitting the ball, also sides with the club. "If Jones and Mackenzie were alive today, seeing what's going on, they certainly would do something," Dye says. "I don't think they'd be offended [by the changes]. Mackenzie certainly had no idea somebody was going to hit the ball 370 yards."On the subject of fast and firm, I thought this was interesting since I'm of the belief that a fast course with the added accoutrements will turn into a freak show:
"The only defense to the course was really firm, fast greens, and there was a point in the '90s where they really crossed the line," Mickelson says. "I saw Jeff Sluman on the second hole have a four-footer uphill, and it spun out on him and then rolled 60 feet off the green. [Since] they've lengthened it, the greens have been very fair … they have not crossed over the line."
Of course, the last few Masters also have been wet ones. There hasn't been a dry week since all that length was added for the 2002 event, which makes some wonder what kind of scenario will play out this year if it doesn't rain for the first time on the new Augusta -- and why the club didn't wait until it got a week of sunshine before renovating the course yet again.
"If it ever gets dry and baked out and it doesn't rain like it did in '99 when Ollie won, and the greens get blue-looking like they did that year," says Woods, "even par or over par will win easily."
Should that happen, the Masters will have come to resemble the U.S. Open, and one wonders if that is the angle the tournament has been after all along.
Accompanying the Golf World piece are these photos (linked from GolfDigest.com) that tell boggle the mind. Note on the first hole how pinched it is between bunker and trees, and the ridiculous looking 7th and 11th holes:



Thanks to reader Tuco for the heads up on Mike Weir's website musings:
The changes are going to make things tough. On the first hole, the new tee is a ways back from where it used to be. Monday morning, into the wind, I hit a pretty big drive and had a rescue club in. I expect without a wind in my face, it will be driver, 3-iron where before it was driver, seven-iron. No one has really mentioned any changes to the second hole, but when I saw it Monday, it seems that the tee is back about 10 yards or so, making it tough to get home in two.
The changes on 11 are big. When I played here a few weeks ago, I hit a solid drive and still had 200 yards to the front. You have to just flat bust it down the left side here and it’s a tight drive now, with trees added to the right. It’s really a dogleg now. But even with a good drive, I think a lot of guys are going to lay up right and take their chances with a Larry Mize-like chip.
The 17th they’ve moved back 15 yards so that makes it significantly different for getting the ball up on the top tier instead of landing it into the hill in the fairway.
...are now posted.
Thanks to reader Noonan for the CBS blog that is debating the Tiger Woods-Ed Bradley deep tissue massage session on 60 Minutes. The question of whether 60 Minutes should somehow make news or tear down the subject is raised. Of course no one wants that, but it's the fist bumps we can do without.
From Thomas Bonk in today's L.A. Times:
"I like the comments that he and Mr. Palmer said about Augusta," DiMarco said. "[Nicklaus] certainly has the right to have an opinion on what he has done to that course."
That "he" is Johnson and he's already the talk of the town.
Jose Maria Olazabal won the Masters in 1994 and 1999 when it was more than 500 yards shorter.
"We have seen the direction they have taken and time will tell if they are right or wrong," Olazabal said.
"It's not a matter of how I want it …. With all the lengthening and everything, some of the pin positions we played through the years, they are not going to be accessible, maybe except for, I don't know, 10 players.
"I don't think by making the golf course longer you are improving the whole situation when you say you are trying to protect the golf course from the long hitters. I think the long hitters, they have the hugest smile, from ear to ear, to be honest."
Other than Fred Couples, everyone else quoted in this David Westin story for the Augusta Chronicle is not very complimentary of the course changes.
Stewart Cink clearly has given the subject a lot more thought than the average tour player and is characterizing the destruction of the Jones-MacKenzie design ideals quite nicely:
"It's still a very good test, but a lot harder test than it's ever been," Stewart Cink said. "It's just not the gem of architecture that is used to be."
"It's just like an American golf course; it used to be linksy," Cink said. "Bobby Jones really wanted that thing to be linksy. We play courses all year out here where you have to drive it between the rough and you have to hit your ball on the green in a certain way."
And Nick Faldo's satirical take ended up not too far off base:
"I'm sure they can start getting the roads moved around on the outside," three-time champion Nick Faldo said in jest. "I'm sure they've got the power to do that. Buy a few houses."
Little did he know, but Faldo might not have been far off the mark. The club's holding companies own more than 145 acres outside its borders.
Todd Hamilton isn't too wild about the demise of options:
"To me, on a good golf course, on every hole you should be able to pick what shot you want to play," Hamilton said. "You shouldn't be forced to hit a shot."
But back to Cink, who understands the shift from a free-market design approach to Hootie Johnson and Tom Fazio's shallower, dictatorial style:
Said Cink: "Augusta was always a place where you could have a lot of fun and you could demonstrate an artistic talent for strategy around the golf course. Now, it's not.
"No. 11 is a hole where you could hit your drive anywhere you wanted to; you could create your own angle, you could make the hole set up any way you wanted to," Cink said. "That was one of the great things about the old course.
"Now the fairway is probably 30 yards wide because they added trees on both sides. Everybody has to hit the same shot. To me, it's just way less interesting than it used to be."
And Jim Furyk explains how some changes have eliminated temptation:
"The way the golf course is set up now with the length, you can't play that aggressively," Jim Furyk said. "You can't have a 9-iron into the 14th green. Before, you had a 9-iron and I might have a go at a back-left pin. If I had a 6-iron in my hand now, I'd have to be a complete moron to go at it."
Whatever happens this week, the constant changing of the storied golf course will be the primary topic of conversation for the foreseeable future. If it's not the length that is offending players, it is certainly the interpretation of design intents that can spark an argument between players and anyone wearing the members' signature green jacket.
For every talking point quote culled from the Jones and Mackenzie archives that would seemingly support the club's changes, there are plenty of counterpoints that would suggest the original designers would cringe at what has been done to their course.
Case in point, the diabolical par-3 fourth hole. Stretched to 240 yards, Jones reportedly offered dueling perspectives.
The club's preferred context: "The shot is usually a strong iron or even a 4- or 3-wood."
The critic's preferred context: "I have never been convinced that a so-called one-shot hole of 240 or 250 yards is a forthright golfing problem."
Masters Chairman Hootie Johnson has said repeatedly that he is trying to "maintain the integrity of the shot values" envisioned by the designers. Numerous players argue that Jones and Mackenzie never envisioned forests of trees corralling competitors into singular options.
When a quiet and reasonable player such as Stewart Cink contends Augusta National "isn't the architectural gem" it once was, it has to give pause to even the course's most hardened defender.
Who knows yet whether it can be fixed - or whether it even needs to be? All that is known is that players today will certainly get to experience what it was like for players of preceding eras to hit longer irons into greens.
But those forebears never got to know what it was like to hit those irons into firm and wickedly fast greens ill-suited for those approaches.
It's an argument that can never be truly resolved in any context.
Mike Clayton, previewing the Masters:
There have been critics of the changes, most notably Arnold Palmer and Jack Nicklaus, and the objections have centred on the use of great length, narrow fairways and trees in an attempt to maintain the relevance of the course in the face of the debacle of modern technology.
Jones might have been particularly upset by the use of trees to reign in the long bombers of the modern game. 'I see no need for a tree on a golf course' was one of his famous utterances.
The equipment rules were designed to stop exactly what has happened but the minds of the scientific geniuses employed by the equipment companies have run rings around the moribund bureaucrats at the USGA and the R and A who are seemingly still in a case of denial.
Augusta is fortunate to have enough room to be continually moving tees back but our best courses like at Royal Melbourne and Kingston Heath have no such luxury and they are in desperate need of preservation by way of a new ball for professionals.
He goes on to look at the struggles of Australian players in the majors and considers possible contenders.
On Wednesday, Hootie Johnson will enter Augusta National's state-of-the-art press building for his annual no-comment session with the world's leading scribblers. He will probably be joined by the club's Chair of Winter Storm Damage Storage, Will Nicholson, and Question Screening Committee Chair, Billy Payne.
First, a question for Nicholson:
And now, here are a few questions I'd love to ask Hootie:
Now online for subscribers at SI.com is the text for the Alister MacKenzie Dream 18, compiled by yours truly, drawn by Gil Hanse and selected with the help of Tom Doak, Mike DeVries, Mike Clayton, Mike Hurdzan and Nick Faldo.
Is anyone else intrigued by the notion that Phil Mickelson is using two drivers, one to shape the ball right to left (the "gamer"), and another for the opposite shot shape?
Golf World's E. Michael Johnson has the details in this story.
In the "skill" debate, I wonder if this will come up as an example where equipment is supplementing skill?
More power to Mickelson for doing what he has to do to win within the rules, but I guess this brings me back to Max Behr's quote about the role of equipment:
I do not think we will go far wrong if we define a true sportsman as one who endeavors to adjust his implements down to a point where they will just sustain his skill, in order that upon skill, and skill alone, must depend the decision of the contest.
A strong case could be made that good players used to use drivers with slightly open or closed faces to create a certain ball flight or to offset a swing flaw.
And I suppose you could say there is skill in determining that you get different reactions from different clubs. But it seems that the real skill in this case was in the club fitting?
Montgomerie then considered how useful the two clubs would be at, say, the 17th and 18th at Wentworth and, again, at the last two holes at the Belfry. "The best thing about the idea," he continued, "is the way you can do away with the need to come up with two different swings."
Thoughts?
Ron Sirak looks at Augusta National's purchases (and attempts) to purchase real estate surrounding the club, estimating that they've spent $22.9 million in the process.
The PGA Tour Driving Distance average rose just a bit from 288.12 after the BellSouth to 288.6 yards. That's nearly 9 yards longer than last year at this point.
There were 12 over-350 or longer drives, bringing the season total to 844. The average percentage of over-300 yard drives rose from 23.8% to 24.04%.
With ShotLink coming to the Augusta National for the first time, it will be interesting to see if the PGA Tour includes the Masters in this year's statistics.
Reader MacDuff gives us his latest breakdown of a possible FedEx Cup points race. Here is a look at the points system he uses. Points and events played are listed next to the player names.
1 Mickelson 12846.87 8
2 Toms 11871.87 7
3 Singh 11609.37 8
4 Sabbatini 10891.66 7
5 Petersson 10233.33 9
6 C.Campbell 10200 9
7 Glover 9854.16 7
8 Donald 9589.37 6
9 Furyk 9587.5 7
10 Pernice 9437.5 7
11 Gf. Ogilvy 9387.5 6
12 Van Pelt 9127.5 9
13 Olazabal 9075 6
14 T.Woods 8859.37 5
15 Lehman 8350 7
16 Weir 8334.37 6
17 Verplank 8187.5 6
18 Oberholser 8137.5 7
19 Villegas 8025 7
20 Rollins 7675 7
21 Parnevik 7567.5 8
22 Z.Johnson 7537.5 7
23 D.Wilson 7425 8
24 Chopra 7424.5 8
25 Goosen 7362.5 5
26 Mayfair 7191.66 7
27 Warren 7112.5 7
28 Bohn 6995.83 7
29 Gay 6925 8
30 Franco 6800 7
31 JB Holmes 6695.83 6
32 Imada 6692.5 7
33 G. Owen 6662.5 6
34 Barlow 6657.5 7
35 Appleby 6650 6
36 Garcia 6550 5
37 Bertsch 6550 7
38 Ames 6500 5
39 Choi 6400 6
40 Funk 6337.5 7
41 Pat Perez 6262.5 7
42 Palmer 6166.66 6
43 Fischer 6150 8
44 Cink 6083.83 6
45 F.Jacobson 6050 5
46 Love III 6037.5 6
47 Rose 5966.66 5
48 T.Clark 5922.5 7
49 JJ Henry 5875 5
50 M.Wilson 5852.5 5
51 J.Ogilvie 5845 6
52 Pampling 5792.5 5
53 Baird 5680 6
54 Bjornstad 5655 6
55 J.Byrd 5500 4
56 Jobe 5392.5 5
57 Vn Taylor 5362.5 5
58 Langer 5354.16 6
59 Hoffman 5332.5 5
60 Jerry Kelly 5325 4
61 N.Green 5262.5 6
62 Els 5200 5
63 Westwood 5187.5 5
64 Calc 5150 7
65 Bub Watson 5075 5
66 Purdy 5037.5 5
67 Couples 5025 6
68 Allenby 5012.5 5
69 D. Howell 4987.5 4
70 Hart 4987.5 5
71 DiMarco 4984.37 4
72 Branshaw 4937.5 5
73 Leonard 4895.83 5
74 RS Johnson 4875 4
75 Bryant 4862.5 5
76 A.Scott 4800 4
77 Triplett 4750 4
78 Watney 4737.5 6
79 Senden 4625 4
80 Beem 4618.75 6
81 Matteson 4600 6
82 J.Smith 4512.5 5
83 Harrington 4487.5 4
84 Olin Browne 4487.5 6
85 Gore 4387.5 4
86 Crane 4345 4
87 Atwal 4312.5 4
88 Howell III 4300 8
89 Sluman 4287.5 8
90 Flesch 4255 6
91 Frazar 4187.5 6
92 Br.Davis 4162.5 6
93 Waldorf 4037.5 5
94 Cook 4000 4
95 Dickerson 3975 7
T96 Veazey 3962.5 4
T96 Kenny Perry 3962.5 4
98 Barron 3943.75 4
99 S.Jones 3912.5 5
100 Curtis 3875 5
101 Faxon 3787.5 5
102 Estes 3775 3
103 Gove 3750 4
104 D.Clarke 3725 3
105 Slocum 3725 6
106 Lonard 3662.5 5
107 Herron 3657.5 4
108 Immelman 3650 4
109 Maggert 3625 6
110 Kaye 3550 4
111 Kent Jones 3537.5 4
112 Micheel 3500 4
113 Cabrera 3475 4
114 Lowery 3462.5 5
115 Geiberger 3287.5 4
116 Sean O'Hair 3287.5 6
117 Stankowski 3265.5 5
T118 Azinger 3112.5 4
T118 Petrovic 3112.5 4
120 Gronberg 3062.5 3
121 H.Stenson 3012.5 3
122 S. Maruyama 3000 5
123 Lickliter II 2912.5 3
124 Ridings 2912.5 4
125 Gamez 2887.5 4
126 Garrigus 2880 4
127 Kevin Na 2875 3
128 Poulter 2875 4
129 WMacKenzie 2837.5 3
130 JL Lewis 2800 5
131 Huston 2762.5 3
132 B. Quigley 2750 3
133 Points 2737.5 3
134 Brehaut 2712.5 6
135 Mahan 2662.5 5
136 Levet 2662.5 6
137 Celka 2645 6
138 Dawson 2500 4
139 M. Cambo 2437.5 2
140 Allen 2400 4
141 Goggin 2387.75 3
142 Pavin 2362.5 3
143 Sindelar 2325 5
144 Stricker 2225 2
145 Driscoll 2175 4
146 Leaney 2125 2
147 Katayama 2121.87 3
148 Baddeley 2100 4
149 Ws Short Jr 2062.5 5
150 Bren Jones 2050 2
151 Durant 2037.5 6
152 Andrade 2032.5 3
Geoff Shackelford is a Senior Writer for Golfweek magazine, a weekly contributor to Golf Channel's Morning
Copyright © 2022, Geoff Shackelford. All rights reserved.