The Gimmick Turned Sound Business Decision

Lawrence Donegan on Michelle Wie's European Masters exemption:
"Michelle has demonstrated her outstanding golfing skills to a global audience as both an amateur and now as a professional, and we look forward to welcoming her," said George O'Grady, the chief executive of the European tour - a remarkable volte-face by a man who had previously been sceptical about offering women invitations to play in men's events.

Eight months ago O'Grady dismissed the practice as a "gimmick". But in golf nothing speaks as loudly as sponsorship money. The European Masters is sponsored by Omega and Wie this year signed a sponsorship deal with the watchmakers.

The Canadian Open Blues

Lorne Rubenstein devotes a Golfobserver.com column to the dire situation with the Canadian Open and it's date on the 2007 PGA Tour schedule, easily the worst possible date you could give an event:
The date's hopeless, but both PGA Tour commissioner Tim Finchem and the Royal Canadian Golf Association's executive director Stephen Ross still said they were "bullish" on the new date when it was announced on January 13th. Another word that begins with "bull" comes to mind.
And...
 The RCGA didn't have any say in the new dates from 2007 forward, and tried to spin its new summer date as wonderful and all that when it was announced.

But really, what sort of field will gather come 2007 when the tournament will be held the week after the British Open, the week before the World Golf Championships-Bridgestone Invitational in Akron, Ohio, and two weeks before the PGA Championship? The Canadian Open could be held in Newfoundland, in the far east of Canada, the RCGA could again charter flights from the British Open, and most top players still won't play the next week.

Let's see: Which of those four tournaments do you think Tiger Woods and his colleagues at the top of the tour will pass on? As for Weir and his fellow Canadian Stephen Ames, they'll have quite a month. The Canadian Open is the fifth major for both Weir and Ames. There's no way they wouldn't play in it.

"The Canadian Open is the perfect week to take off," Zokol said. "The PGA Tour gave the tournament the dates because it doesn't have a sponsor. It's the RCGA's fault for not keeping pace. The PGA Tour moved the tournament to the back of the bus."

Hawkins On FedEx Cup Debate

Golf World's John Hawkins says the Tour is going to present a model for the FedEx Cup, and I know you have all been waiting anxiously to see what they've come up with. He writes:

Although points will replace dollars as the official measure of a player’s position in the standings, the difference could prove to be quite minimal, as one might surmise by the basics of the proposal:

    • All “regular” tour events will award a total of 25,000 points. The World Golf Championships will award 26,250, with the four majors and the Players Championship worth 27,500.

    • The winner of each tournament will receive 18 percent of the total points—the same percentage as a standard purse breakdown—meaning Brett Wetterich’s triumph at the EDS Byron Nelson Championship would have earned him 4,500 points. All players who make the cut will receive points.
On the point of money list and points synergy, MacDuff's season long take (the most recent results posted below) indicate that equal points throughout the schedule would actually create some interesting differences in the money/points lists, and reward those who play more often.

The current standings based on Money (M) and FedEx Cup Points (F) as compiled by reader MacDuff.

M   F
1    1    Phil Mickelson     
2    4    Jim Furyk     
3    8    Stuart Appleby
4    6    Geoff Ogilvy     
5    21    Tiger Woods     
6    5    Chad Campbell     
7    10    Rory Sabbatini     
8    9    David Toms     
9    14    Retief Goosen     
10    35    Stephen Ames     
11    3    Vijay Singh     
12    12    Luke Donald     
13    19    Jose Maria Olazabal
14    38    Trevor Immelman     
15    17    Arron Oberholser     
16    54    Brett Wetterich       
17    30    Adam Scott     
18    2    Lucas Glover     
19    27    Rod Pampling     
20    18    Tim Clark     
21    15    Scott Verplank     
22    46    Camilo Villegas       
23    42    Zach Johnson     
24    72    Aaron Baddeley     
25    59    J.B. Holmes    

Hawkins also writes about how the playoff series will work and ends with this:

   • The size of the field for the season-ending Tour Championship has not been determined. There has been talk of reducing the playoff fields from 144 to 132, then to 120, then perhaps to 60 for the Tour Championship. The issue is likely to become a key topic of conversation at the PAC meeting.

Now that's funny! 144 to 132, then 120, then 60 for the Tour Championship. Oh what a thrilling playoff run it will be! Tune in tomorrow to find out if Hunter Mahan will hold off a charge from Frank Lickliter to see who gets into the Tournament Formerly Known As The Westchester Classic.

If the tour reduced the number of playoff qualifiers to 80, then eliminated 20 guys each week so that only 20 remained for the Tour Championship, we’d have the type of cut-throat, nerve-melting format that is needed. The proposed system is a giant compromise to the tour’s middle class, dangerously hyper and far too bloated to have the same stimulating effect as NASCAR’s year-end series, in which only 10 cars compete.

Great...oops, there's more.

Of course, no sports league rewards mediocrity better than the PGA Tour. It answers to a bulky constituency, diluting its product for the sake of short-sighted individual gain, failing to realize that the boat would move much faster with a lot fewer oars in the water.     

Sigh.

MacDuff's Post Byron Nelson FedEx Cup Points Standings

MacDuff reports Brett Wetterich moved from 102nd last week to 54th with his win; Trevor Immelman was 102nd two weeks ago, 55th last week (and now 38th) in a mythical 2006 FedEx Cup points race. And for those Omar Uresti fans, he's 180th with 2137.5 points.

Do note that MacDuff has awarded the same points from week to week, with nothing special for majors or WGC's, while the tour is contemplating added extra points for winners of those majors and wannabe majors and other elite field events.
          
1    Mickelson    17509.37        11
2    Glover    15854.16        11
3    Singh    15221.87        12
4    Furyk    15212.5        10
5    C.Campbell    14637.5        12
6    Gf. Ogilvy    13762.5        9
7    Pettersson    13258.33        13
8    Appleby    12662.5        10
9    Toms    12409.37        8
10    Sabbatini    12366.66        10
11    Van Pelt    12015        13
12    Donald    12014.37        8
13    Weir    12009.37        9
14    Goosen    11775        8
15    Verplank    11612.5        9
16    Mayfair    11279.16        10
17    Oberholser    11075        10
18    T.Clark    10897.5        10
19    Olazabal    10875        7
20    Parnevik    10767.5        12
21    T.Woods    10659.37        6
22    Pernice    10650        8
23    Bohn    10288.33        10
24    Els    10037.5        9
25    Warren    10012.5        10
26    Gay    9787.5        10
27    Pampling    9772.5        9
28    Cink    9708.83        9
29    Lehman    9700        9
30    A.Scott    9625        7
31    D.Wilson    9512.5        10
32    Hoffman    9425        9
33    Funk    9262.5        9
34    Vn Taylor    9225        8
35    Ames    9162.5        7
36    Love III    9112.5        9
37    Choi    9087.5        8
38    Immelman    9000        7
39    Watney    8912.5        10
40    Purdy    8825        9
41    Jerry Kelly    8625        7
42    Z.Johnson    8475        8
43    Chopra    8267        10
T44    JJ Henry    8225        7
T44    Senden    8225        7
46    Villegas    8225        8
47    Howell III    8137.5        12
48    J.Ogilvie    8120        8
49    Franco    8087.5        8
50    B. Quigley    8037.5        7
51    G. Owen    7975        8
52    Harrington    7962.5        7
53    Garcia    7900        7
54    Wetterich    7850        6
55    Bertsch    7775        9
56    Rollins    7675        7
57    Estes    7537.5        7
58    Imada    7517.5        9
59    JB Holmes    7420.83        7
60    Branshaw    7325        8
61    Palmer    7316.66        8
62    Micheel    7275        8
63    Leonard    7258.33        8
64    J.Smith    7200        7
65    Herron    7170        7
66    Rose    7129.16        9
67    Sluman    7112.5        11
68    Waldorf    6987.5        8
69    Lowery    6975        9
70    Crane    6945        7
71    Jobe    6892.5        7
72    Baddeley    6850        7
73    Couples    6825        7
74    Olin Browne    6787.5        11
75    Beem    6768.75        8
76    RS Johnson    6767.5        7
77    Barlow    6712.5        8
78    Hart    6692.5        7
79    Langer    6541.66        8
80    Baird    6517.5        7
81    Fischer    6425        9
82    M.Wilson    6390        6
83    Calc    6342.5        10
84    D. Howell    6262.5        5
85    Pat Perez    6262.5        7
86    Bjornstad    6217.5        7
87    Allenby    6187.5        6
88    Poulter    6175        7
89    N.Green    6137.5        8
90    F.Jacobson    6075        6
91    Bryant    6050        6
92    B. Haas    6025        7
93    Br.Davis    5992.5        8
94    JL Lewis    5987.5        9
95    Bub Watson    5962.5        6
96    Sutherland    5900        8
97    S. Maruyama    5800        7
98    Flesch    5755        9
99    Gove    5737.5        6
100    DiMarco    5696.87        6
101    Slocum    5687.5        8
102    Atwal    5625        5
103    Gore    5525        6
104    J.Byrd    5500        4
105    Durant    5400        9
106    Curtis    5375        7
107    Gronberg    5312.5        5
108    Barron    5306.25        6
109    Leaney    5287.5        6
110    Stricker    5212.5        4
111    Westwood    5187.5        5
112    Sindelar    5187.5        7
113    Goggin    5125.25        5
114    Cabrera    5100        5
115    Matteson    5037.5        7
116    Lonard    4975        7
117    Maggert    4937.5        7
118    D.Clarke    4900        4
119    Triplett    4800        5
120    Kenny Perry    4762.5        5
121    Azinger    4762.5        7
122    Ws Short Jr    4612.5        9
123    Pavin    4587.5        5
T124    Geiberger    4575        7
T124    Sean O'Hair    4575        7
126    Mahan    4525        8
127    Dickerson    4450        8
128    Faxon    4362.5        7
129    Armour III    4275        5
130    Lickliter II    4250        5
131    Andrade    4207.5        7
132    Frazar    4187.5        6
133    Austin    4162.5        9
134    S.Jones    4030        7
135    Veazey    4025        5
136    Cook    4000        4
137    Ridings    3887.5        6
138    Kent Jones    3612.5        5
139    McCarron    3587.5        6
140    Kaye    3575        5

USGA Exempts Wie To Women's Open

Their reasoning on Wie makes sense:

Wie, the 2003 U.S. Women’s Amateur Public Links champion, has two third-place finishes in her first two LPGA tournaments in 2006. She finished third at the Fields Open and tied for third at the Kraft Nabisco Championship. In those two events, she has won $181,449, which would place her within the top 35 on the LPGA Tour money list if she were a full-time member of the Tour. In 2005, she made the cut in all four major events, with a second-place finish at the McDonald’s LPGA Championship and a tie for third at the Weetabix Women’s British Open. Were she a professional, she would have earned $697,144 to finish 12th on the 2005 LPGA money list. 

Hopkins Reviews Wentworth West Renovation

John Hopkins in the Times reviews the redesigned West Course at Wentworth, which has been getting universally wretched reviews from devotees who have seen it.

It has regained some of its testing qualities and although there are a couple of places where Els’s enthusiasm might have overruled his sense of what Colt was trying to do, he has, overall, updated the 80-year-old masterpiece with reverence. Take the 6th and 8th holes, for example.
He proceeds to describe many strange sounding features, which I just didn't have the heart to copy and paste. Young children might be reading.

 

One had not realised quite how much Els knows or cares about the ground beneath his feet and the trees and shrubs that line the fairways. Spend time with him on a golf course and you understand not only that he has an appreciation of colour and beauty but that he has a devilish eye for where to position bunkers. This is not to mention details he has at his fingertips, such as the width of a fairway, the roll of a bunker, the borrow of a green.

One appears to be starstruck too. 

NCAA Regional Madness

Golfweek's Ron Balicki tries to explain some of the absurdities in the NCAA golf committee's tournament selection setup, namely sending Top 5 teams Florida and UCLA out of their regions (and to each others regions).

Ryan Herrington is even less forgiving in his latest Golf Digest college golf blog post.

The regionals kick off Thursday, with 54 holes played at three sites: Sand Ridge, Lake Nona and Tucson National.  

Old Course-Winged Foot-Pebble Beach In A Day...With Bobby Clampett!

George Peper's latest Links column looks at his unique one day feat of playing St. Andrews, Winged Foot and Pebble Beach in a day, which is a big deal until you realize that he did it with Bobby Clampett.
 On July 18, 1983, my foursome completed 18 holes on the West Course in precisely two hours and 16 minutes. If that doesn’t take your breath away, consider this: 1) on that morning we’d traveled more than 3,500 miles to get there; 2) it was our second round of the day; and 3) that afternoon we went another 18 holes—and another 2,500 miles.

I was editor of GOLF Magazine back then and one of my core duties was to make noise for the magazine—occasionally do nutty things that attracted attention and, by extension, readers and advertisers. In a moment of questionable inspiration I came up with the notion of playing St. Andrews, Winged Foot and Pebble Beach in 24 hours.

I wonder how many weather forecasts Clampett issued?

Hawkins on Ratings Decline

John Hawkins looks at the dismal PGA Tour ratings with his latest blog entry:

The first four months of 2006 did not bear good news for the PGA Tour in terms of its popularity with television viewers. Figures published in the most recent issue of Street & Smith’s SportsBusiness Journal indicate some frightening drops in TV ratings. The Shell Houston Open, for example, had a Sunday audience about one-third smaller than in 2005. There were double-digit decreases (10 percent or more) at the first three events on the Florida Swing, a whopping 56.3-percent decline at the Bob Hope Chrysler Classic and a 50-percent loss at the season-opening Mercedes Championships.

February’s AT&T Pebble Beach National Pro-Am, a tournament once capable of attracting five million viewers, checked in at about 2.5 million on Sunday, down 37.5 percent from a year earlier. Not every tournament’s numbers were off. The Players Championship actually rose almost 32 percent, but there’s a catch—rain delays in ’05 forced NBC to televise live third-round action that Sunday.
So you're thinking, he's going to point out how the juiced up power game is not relatable to fans, course setups are not producing more consistently exciting finishes and that the Tour has left too many classic venues for contrived ones?
The PGA TOUR has not downsized enough and it is going to have to become leaner and meaner to survive.

I say bring back "blood and guts" competition to the PGA tour as played by Ben Hogan, Sam Snead, a young Arnie, Gary and Jack and other great players when men were men as well as golfers.

When men were men as well as golfers? Oh lordy. Still, he's headed to the old bring shotmaking back argument? Nope.

Cut the number of tour cards to a max of 100, cut the number of players in the field to 100 and cut the cut to the top 50 and ties.

Put some damn fire back into the competition and maybe golf will be interesting as a spectator sport once again and not seem to be just a gathering of nice fellows content to make a good check and have a good time. Screw the good time, get serious!
Shouldn't there be a rule that you only get to question the passion or manliness of players if you actually played the Tour?

 

Turnberry Turns 100

turnberry-lighthouse.jpgTom English pens a nice overview of Turnberry's 100th birthday for Scotland on Sunday.

In the Second World War the government commandeered the golf course just as they had in the First. They made a military air station of it, put 1,200 men on site and told those who wanted to know that golf had probably had its day at Turnberry. The links had survived one conflict. It was unlikely to survive a second.

The bulldozers moved in. Greens were ploughed up and several thousand tonnes of concrete and tarmac were poured on to fairways to make runways.
How times have not changed...they're revving up the dozers again.
It's a challenge that is going to get stiffer by the time 2009 comes around. It would have been appropriate for Turnberry to host the Open in this their 100th year but change was needed there. Foul weather defended the course against the bombers of today but you'd fear for it if the modern pros cut loose in dry conditions. The fear is they'd tear it to pieces. The game has changed a lot since Nick Price won there in 1994. Apart from the infrastructure around the course, they needed to toughen-up the Ailsa.

The changes are pretty radical, even if the R&A has asked for some of them to be undone. They were concerned the new and extensive bunkering on some holes was too penal and would force players to go defensive off the tee. Some have been filled in completely, others have been made less deep. Still, there will be approaching 30 new traps when the Open returns there and about 200 extra yards to negotiate.

The most dramatic alteration is the shifting of the 10th tee 50 yards to the left. Dinna Fouter now requires a 220-yard carry over the sea to find the fairway. Anything remotely hooky will end up wet. It's a hole to challenge the signature ninth, with all the stunning views of the lighthouse and the Ailsa Craig. It is a vision that brings to mind Henry Longhurst's plaintive words in troubled times.

"In those long periods inseparable from wartime service when there is nothing to do but sit and think," he wrote, "I often used to find myself sitting and thinking of the time when once again we might be playing golf at Turnberry."