When you come to think of it that is the secret of most of the great holes all over the world. They all have some kind of a twist. C.B. MACDONALD
There isn't much to quibble with at Muirfield Village and the Memorial, one of the premier tournaments in the world and a model for sporting event operations. The magnificently conditioned course only adds to its allure, but if there was one quibble for this first time visitor to the Memorial, it's that, uh, well, peculiarly-designed 16th green as redesigned by Jack Nicklaus in 2010 and debuted in 2011.
It just doesn't fit with the rest, nor does No. 16 come close to working from the angle in question, no matter what wind is blowing.
As I noted in a video earlier this week, the hole looks like a fun, enticing but still-scary from a distance approximately 40 yards shorter and 40 yards right of the current tees, though a total green redo would not be the worst thing to happen either.
But after this shot for the ages by Tiger Woods, I'm having a hard time seeing Mr. Nicklaus bulldozing his redo.
So sorry boys! You're stuck with it!
Check out this ShotLink scatter chart screen grab of the 16th green tee shots from round 4. The hole finished as the toughest for the week. It was virtually impossible to hit a shot close.
Mr. Nicklaus was asked about No. 16 after the round and a funny exchange broke out involving Tiger and Jon Brendle of the tour staff:
Q. Jack, you redesigned 16 to put a little more excitement into the tournament. How do you think that's worked out?
JACK NICKLAUS: Well, today‑‑ we had wind all week. The first day wasn't bad. The pin was tucked in the first pin placement the first day. But today, I don't think the field staff‑‑ I think the field staff got caught a little bit. They were forecasting for a southwest wind, we had a northwest wind, and with the northwest wind that back pin placement from the back tee was really tough. That wasn't what I had in mind to be very honest with you. That green with a southwest wind funnels right down the green, meaning that if you're standing back there on the tee and you hit it, you're going to be buffeted slightly from the right and it should turn the ball. The old green went this way, this green goes this way, so it should feed it to the green.
But when you've got a strong left to right, don't put the pin in the back left, please. It just made it so the guys couldn't play it. Not many guys did, they really just needed to put the ball in the middle of the green there if they could and then try to make a two‑putt. But guys kept trying to force it back there and they kept going to the back of the green or going in the back bunker and it was tough.
TIGER WOODS: Oh, really?
JACK NICKLAUS: It was tough. It was tough. I'm glad I didn't have to play my own hole.
That's probably right, isn't it, Jon?
JON BRENDLE: You guys were forecasting southwest. I don't know. We wanted to play it tough for you.
JACK NICKLAUS: No, I don't want you to play it right for me. I want you to play it right.
JON BRENDLE: We knew it was going to be tough all day.
JACK NICKLAUS: That's your call, not my call. Jon and I talked during the week, we had five pin placements, you didn't use the back right. You could've used back right today probably with the way the wind was.
JON BRENDLE: I thought it was more fair back right.
JACK NICKLAUS: Boy, you're mean.
TIGER WOODS: I made 2. (Laughter.)
JACK NICKLAUS: Yeah, he made 2. The little pin placement on the right he made 2, also. You played that hole a couple under?
TIGER WOODS: I did play it a couple under.
JACK NICKLAUS: So what's so tough about it? Isn't the hole supposed to separate you?
TIGER WOODS: Here we go.
Until the PGA Tour puts up a clean copy, a fan capture **8:33 ET Tiger's shot from the CBS telecast of the 2012 Memorial goes live on YouTube:
**So where does this one rank with these shots?
**Great stuff from Tiger and Jack after the round, talking about the shot on 16:
Q. Mr.Nicklaus mentioned out on the green during closing ceremonies he's never seen a better shot than your chip‑in on 16. Take us through that.
TIGER WOODS: The shot was really difficult, but it wouldn't have been so bad if I had a good lie. If the lie was decent, it would not have brought water into play. That was the thing. The lie was just a little bit marginal where it brought water into play. That's one of the reasons why I took such a big cut at it is to try to under cut it enough so if I missed it I missed it short and if it had enough speed it wouldn't snag it and tug it long left, so obviously the hosel wouldn't have been snagged by the grass.
I went for it. I pulled it off, and for it to land as soft as it did was kind of a surprise because it was baked out and it was also downhill running away from me. It just fell in. I didn't think it was going to get there at one point. Kind of like 16 at Augusta, I thought I was going to leave it short somehow, and then it fell in.
Q. Where does that rank amongst some of your best shots, whether it be the 16th at Augusta or maybe when you holed out at Hoylake, or I don't know where you would put that one.
TIGER WOODS: It was one of the hardest ones I've pulled off. I think probably the hardest pitch not too many people saw was the one in Japan in the World Cup to get into the playoff. But obviously you guys never saw it. (Laughter.)
That was a pretty sweet shot.
But this one was a good one. As I said, it wouldn't have been so bad if the lie was better. But as I said, the lie was sketchy enough where it brought water into play.
CHRIS REIMER: Mr.Nicklaus, I know you congratulated Tiger out at closing ceremonies and you mentioned 16. Some opening comments from you?
JACK NICKLAUS: I think that‑‑ I just said out here a couple times, that under the circumstances, the circumstances being Tiger has been struggling, he found himself in a position in a tournament, and it was either fish or cut bait, he had one place to land the ball, he's playing a shot that if he leaves it short, he's going to leave himself again a very difficult shot, if he hits it long, he's going to probably lose the tournament. He lands the ball exactly where it has to land. It doesn't make a difference whether it went in the hole or not. Going in the hole was a bonus. But what a shot. I don't think under the circumstances I've ever seen a better shot.
Michael Buteau with the news of agent Mark Steinberg's Ardley Ardsley, New York checkpoint arrest for "aggravated" driving while intoxicated at 10:30 p.m. Saturday night.
“He did inform us who he was,” Fisher said in a telephone interview. “It is what it is. He was intoxicated.”
Steinberg, in an e-mail, said “it’s a medical issue that I was dealing with. It’s not what you think.”
Fisher said Steinberg gave no indication of a medical issue.
“It was alcohol related,” Fisher said. “He submitted to a chemical test to determine alcohol-blood content and he failed that test.”
**Jason Sobel asked Tiger about the DWI in his post-Memorial presser:
Q. Last night your agent Mark Steinberg was arrested on dunk driving charges. Did you know that before the round, and what are your thoughts?
TIGER WOODS: Yeah, I did, and no comment.
**Mick Rouse Tweeted the Steinberg mugshot:
And the arrest report making the rounds and sure to become an IMG office refrigerator favorite.
Who knew the PGA of America's Glory's Last Shot would encourage a slew of slogan's for tournaments seemingly not in need of any introduction?
So for the U.S. Open (Golf's Toughest Test), Golf Channel unveils Monday coverage of U.S. Open Sectional Qualifying (Golf's Longest Day). For Immediate Release:
GOLF CHANNEL PREPARES FOR MAJOR TV FEAT AND 'GOLF'S LONGEST DAY'
June 4 to be Golf’s Version of ‘Super Tuesday’
Reporters at 14 U.S. Sites Will Follow More Than 1,000 Hopefuls Attempting to Qualify for the U.S. Open Championship
ORLANDO, Fla. (June 1, 2012) - Dreams of playing on one of golf’s brightest stages either will be realized or dashed on June 4 for nearly 1,000 golfers who will attempt to qualify for a mere 79 slots available in the final field of 156 players for the 2012 U.S. Open Championship. Through a first-of-its-kind golf television undertaking, Golf Channel will devote an entire day of programming and updates in order to follow these compelling stories during what the network is calling Golf’s Longest Day, or more commonly known as U.S. Open Sectional Qualifying.
Starting at 7 a.m. ET and lasting until Midnight (or when final results are in), Golf Channel will feature interviews, analysis and scoring updates delivered by a team of more than 50 reporters and production professionals embedded at 14 locations throughout the United States. In addition to the 11 USGA Sectional Qualifying sites, the network also will have reporters located at The Olympic Club in San Francisco – site of next month’s U.S. Open – and at USGA headquarters in Far Hills, N.J. All of the content throughout the day will be hosted by Steve Sands and Kelly Tilghman from Golf Channel’s Orlando studios.
Golf’s Longest Day will begin with an expanded, four-hour version of Morning Drive, hosted by Gary Williams. The telecast will include live and taped reports from the 11 sectional qualifiers, as well as interviews with USGA members past and present. Mark Hill, former executive director of the Kentucky Golf Association who ran USGA qualifiers for many years, will serve as a special in-studio expert and will be featured on Golf Channel throughout the day. Hill now serves as USGA senior director of competitions, overseeing the Association’s 12 national amateur events.
Three Golf Central special presentations (1-2 p.m. ET; 6-8 p.m. ET; and 10 p.m.-12 a.m. ET) will cover emerging stories, interviews with medalists and other qualifiers, and studio analysis from Tripp Isenhour (who has qualified for the U.S. Open three out of seven attempts in the past) and Hill. In between, frequent news updates throughout the day will keep viewers up to date on all the news and scores. GolfChannel.com also will serve as a source for U.S. Open qualifying news and information, with feature stories written by correspondents in the field, scoring updates and posting social media content from Golf Channel reporters covering the Sectional events.
I chatted with PGA Tour VP of Rules and Competitions Mark Russell here at The Memorial and he gives a fun answer to the question of phoned-in rule violations, as well as some fresh insights into last week's Zach Johnson situation at Colonial, while revealing that Slugger White was watching the telecast and caught the violation.
How about that great play from the lad, such a turnarou...what? Oh, that Rory? Really? The courtesy car ditcher?
That other Rory – Rory Sabbatini – played his best golf in the worst weather Friday at the Memorial and made a surprising appearance atop the leaderboard. Right behind him was a Tiger Woods that looked all too familiar.
He also noted this about Tiger, who lurks one back in search of his 73rd PGA Tour victory.
Woods looked strong for the second straight day, though he also had another double bogey that slowed his progress. What pleased him was controlling his ball in the wind for plenty of birdie chances that led to a 69.
''I hit the ball well all day, and it was a day that I needed to,'' Woods said. ''The wind was blowing out there, swirling in those trees, and it was just a tough day.''
Steve Elling noted that Woods did this with horrible allergies Thursday, and now a cold or flu bug that developed in round two.
Tiger Woods politely declined to shake hands with a couple of folks after his round at the Memorial Tournament, and not because he was upset with his round or didn't wanna mingle with the little people.
Somewhere over the course of the week, and it wasn't helped by the rain and 50-degree weather on Friday, he caught a cold of flu bug.
“Dude, this is June, right?” Woods said.
As for McIlroy, Dave Shedloski called it "another inexplicable display of desultory golf."
On the par-5 11th, McIlroy layed up poorly on the edge of a creek right of the fairway and then watched his third kick backwards into the water when he tried to hack his ball into the fairway from a thick lie.
"Probably a bit of bad judgment because I thought I could just chip it back out," said McIlroy, who finished fifth in last year's Memorial. "But if I had have examined the line maybe a little bit closer, I might have just taken a drop straight away."
When he drove into another creek left of the fairway at 14, it marked the fourth time that McIlroy had found a water hazard in two rounds.
Bob Harig noted that Rory's lousy play probably still won't be scrutinized like Tiger's.
And yet, you won't see McIlroy take the same kind of bashing Woods would receive if had missed three straight cuts. There will be no cries for McIlroy to dump his swing coach, Michael Bannon, who came over from Northern Ireland to help his star student this week.
Jim McCabe talked to Luke Donald, who sounded very excited to be chatting about his rival, but did offer a blunt take on Rory's troubles.
Donald shrugged.
“He made a few errors, careless errors. I’m sure when Rory puts a few solid rounds together he’ll be fine.”
Elling looked at Rory's day, with full quotes from the lad, and noted how long it's been since Rory played this poorly:
McIlroy, 23, last missed three straight cuts in August, 2008, on the European Tour.
Ashleigh Ignelzi and I discussed the first two rounds of the Memorial. It's about 5 minutes long:
And the PGA Tour highlights include Tiger's 194-yard 8-iron at 16.
Geoff Shackelford is a Senior Writer for Golfweek magazine, a weekly contributor to Golf Channel's Morning
Copyright © 2022, Geoff Shackelford. All rights reserved.
