Winged Foot Interactive Map
/A very cool interactive map and other Winged Foot insights by Brett Avery is now posted at GolfDigest.com
It’s back!
Twenty years later Tatra Press has kindly allowed me to bring back Grounds For Golf now that golf architecture is of more interest to the masses. A new Introduction looks at what’s driven the interest growth and two new chapters I had a blast adding (plus a few edits to keep things up-to-date).
The Amazon purchase page for the book arriving June 15, 2026.
A very cool interactive map and other Winged Foot insights by Brett Avery is now posted at GolfDigest.com
Richard Sandomir in the New York Times writes about a new Nike ad remembering Earl Woods that will debut this week:
Nike naturally looks to create interest around Woods, especially around the time of golf's four major tournaments. "We see a major as a brand moment," said Adam Roth, Nike's United States advertising director.
Lorne Rubenstein wonders what fairness really means as he weighs the pro and cons of "tiered rough" and asks, "Why try to turn it into a controlled laboratory setting?"
Mike Aitken looks at poor Monty: "In his pomp, Colin Montgomerie would have taken one look at how the United States Golf Association set up Winged Foot for this week's US Open and rubbed his hands with glee."
Jane McManus of the Journal News analyzes the media's relationship with Tiger Woods and includes these surprising remarks from Johnny Miller, who just gave Peter Kostis hope for getting back in Tiger's good graces:
"Every time I've asked him a question, I can honestly say he's never given me a real answer. Never once. And I've been pretty nice to him. I feel like he's never given me the respect I deserve. "I know that's a strong statement. I've never said that to anybody. But I really believe that he should take the time when somebody in our industry is trying to tell the real story, that he is willing to give the real answer."
Speaking of Woods, Doug Ferguson writes about his Monday practice round.
Leonard Shapiro ponders the high rough and offers this from Phil Mickelson:
"I'm going to make a bold prediction that someone hits the wrong ball in the rough [during the Open]. A lot of members have been playing, and when they hit in the rough, you can't find it. I've had Bones fore-caddie and he sees where the ball goes and he still can't find it. I think there are not just hundreds, but thousands of balls in the rough you just can't see. This is so thick the grass grows over the ball. You could be standing right over it and still not see it."
And Golf Digest has started a U.S. Open blog, highlighted by a post from Bob Carney on the rough and the pace of the greens.
The USGA's annual Executive Director/President/Championship Committee Chair media session takes place Wednesday morning at 11 a.m. when the scribblers will be fresh from their GWAA meeting convened to argue about the awards contest.
So for those that do stick around, here are a few questions to consider along with (hopefully) reader questions on the comments page of this thread (hopefully, because there were technical issues on Monday...my apologies):
- The 2002 Joint Statement of Principles warned that any "significant" increase in distance from would result in USGA/R&A action. From 2002 to 2005, the same increase in PGA Tour driving distance average has occurred as from 1999 to 2002. Is this cause for action regardless of any further study?
- Many of the fairways here are less than 25 yards wide, including on holes with significant fairway tilt. Is there a width that you would say is too narrow for championship play, and why is it that the fairways are so much narrower than when the U.S. Open was last played here?
- Mr. Driver, what is your stance on the Ohio Golf Association's use of a tournament ball in its Champions event this summer?
- Mr. Hyler, is it permissible for the OGA to use this ball as part of a "condition of competition," while still playing under USGA rules for the competition?
- Can you explain what aspects of the job of USGA President require a private jet for travel, and why the records of this travel are kept confidential?
- As a follow up, why can't the USGA at least provide passenger lists for the trips taken to assure its members that only USGA officers are using this unnecessary privilege?
- As a follow up to the follow up, how much money has been spent on this jet to date?
- How has construction of the new Arnold Palmer Center progressed since the groundbreaking ceremony and when do you expect it to open?
- If the final top 10 of this U.S. Open featured the top 10 players in the world and was won by the world's #1 ranked player, but the winning score was 20-under par, would this still be considered a successful championship?
- For Mr. Driver: It's been nearly a year since you were announced as President, are there any specific accomplishments you are most proud of to this point, and what accomplishments are you hoping to achieve?
- For the panel, with the usual apologies to Colbert: Tom Meeks, great course setup man, or the greatest course setup man?
![]()
(click on image to enlarge)His description here is of the hole as a par-5, and of course this is one of the two three-shotters reduced to a par-4. ![]()
(click on image to enlarge)
I had no modern comparison shots with the old image, but this fairway view should be enough. Love the soft, natural fairway lines too!
You have to love the Rolex Women's World Golf Rankings, where Michelle Wie lands at No. 2 while Lorena Ochoa (2 wins in 2006, 9 Top 10s in 12 starts) and Karrie Webb (1, T2 in majors along with 2 wins and 6 Top 10s in 10 starts) finish behind third and fourth respectively.
But more importantly, what's with the "Korea, Republic of" stuff. And the quotation marks?
Well the FedEx Cups Points race is really, well, it's doing something even though we aren't sure what. As always, thanks to reader MacDuff for his compilation, which does not give extra points for majors or WGC's.
1 Mickelson 20559 13
2 Singh 18509.37 14
3 Furyk 17687.5 12
4 Toms 16196.87 11
5 Gf. Ogilvy 15987.5 11
6 Glover 15879.16 12
7 Pettersson 15758.33 14
8 C.Campbell 15587.5 13
9 Van Pelt 15252.5 16
10 Appleby 14987.5 12
11 Weir 14396.87 12
12 Pernice 14325 11
13 Sabbatini 13754.16 12
14 Donald 13739.37 9
15 Pampling 13697.5 12
16 A.Scott 13375 9
17 B. Quigley 13375 11
18 Oberholser 13312.5 12
19 Z.Johnson 13075 11
20 Goosen 12937.5 10
21 Bohn 12913.33 13
22 Cink 12871.33 11
23 Olazabal 12662.5 9
24 Mayfair 12654.16 13
25 Gay 12525 12
26 T.Clark 12285 12
27 Vn Taylor 12137.5 10
28 Immelman 12087.5 9
29 Verplank 12037.5 10
30 Funk 11912.5 12
31 Senden 11600 10
32 Love III 11412.5 11
33 Purdy 11312.5 11
34 D.Wilson 11112.5 12
35 Lehman 11075 11
36 Herron 11022.5 10
37 Ames 10862.5 8
38 Parnevik 10767.5 12
39 T.Woods 10659.37 6
40 Choi 10537.5 10
41 Hoffman 10375 10
42 Jerry Kelly 10325 9
43 RS Johnson 10305 10
44 Els 10077.5 10
45 Villegas 10062.5 10
46 Imada 10055 11
47 Watney 10025 11
48 Warren 10012.5 10
49 Wetterich 9775 7
50 Leonard 9683.33 11
51 Crane 9660 10
52 Palmer 9466.66 11
53 J.Ogilvie 9345 10
54 JJ Henry 9162.5 9
55 Sluman 9137.5 13
56 Garcia 9112.5 8
57 Waldorf 9087.5 11
58 F.Jacobson 9062.5 8
59 Rose 9041.66 11
60 Chopra 8992 11
61 Jobe 8905 10
62 Estes 8837.5 9
63 Maggert 8812.5 9
64 Harrington 8775 8
65 Bertsch 8750 11
66 Hart 8680 9
67 G. Owen 8662.5 9
68 Poulter 8612.5 9
69 Rollins 8537.5 9
70 N.Green 8415 11
71 Howell III 8362.5 13
72 D. Howell 8262.5 7
73 Baird 8242.5 8
74 Micheel 8162.5 9
75 Azinger 8162.5 10
76 Bryant 8150 8
77 Franco 8112.5 9
78 DiMarco 7959.37 9
79 Couples 7950 9
80 Flesch 7807.5 13
81 Lonard 7787.5 10
82 Lowery 7700 10
83 Austin 7500 12
84 S. Maruyama 7462.5 9
85 Allenby 7450 7
86 JB Holmes 7420.83 7
87 Calcavecchia 7367.5 13
88 Branshaw 7325 8
89 Beem 7293.75 9
90 J.Smith 7225 8
91 Faxon 7125 10
92 Langer 7079.16 9
93 Olin Browne 7075 12
94 Pavin 7062.5 7
95 Sindelar 7037.5 10
96 Sutherland 7012.5 9
97 Bjornstad 7005 9
98 Barlow 7000 9
99 Baddeley 6962.5 8
100 JL Lewis 6937.5 11
101 Bub Watson 6850 7
102 Sean O'Hair 6849.5 9
103 Goggin 6675.25 6
104 Slocum 6475 9
105 Fischer 6425 9
106 M.Wilson 6415 7
107 Gronberg 6350 7
108 Cook 6275 6
109 Triplett 6275 7
110 Pat Perez 6262.5 7
111 Stricker 6225 5
112 Barron 6218.75 8
113 Kenny Perry 6125 7
114 Andrade 6082.5 8
115 B. Haas 6050 8
116 Geiberger 6037.5 8
117 Br.Davis 5992.5 8
118 Durant 5987.5 11
119 Curtis 5775 9
120 Gove 5737.5 6
121 Leaney 5712.5 7
122 Atwal 5650 6
123 Gore 5525 6
124 J.Byrd 5500 4
125 Ws Short Jr 5462.5 11
126 Mahan 5225 10
127 Westwood 5187.5 5
128 Cabrera 5100 5
129 Matteson 5037.5 7
T130 Kaye 4962.5 8
T130 Overton 4962.5 8
132 Lickliter II 4950 7
133 Petrovic 4925 7
134 D.Clarke 4900 4
135 Gamez 4800 8
136 Armour III 4700 6
137 Allen 4562.5 8
138 Dickerson 4450 8
139 Tway 4425 8
140 Nick Price 4300 4
The Wall Street Journal's Carrick Mollenkamp considers the cult status that Tom Doak's Confidential Guide to Golf Courses has attained:
In the book, Mr. Doak reviewed the design features of more than 800 courses, from little-known links to some of the world's most famous and exclusive courses. He gave each a ranking of zero to 10 on what he called the Doak Scale. A zero, Mr. Doak wrote, is "a course so contrived and unnatural that it may poison your mind." But a 10 is "nearly perfect.... If you haven't seen all the courses in this category, you don't know how good golf architecture can get."
Mr. Doak never imagined it back then, but the book has become a cult classic -- a haven of bluntness in a sport that is often so clubby that it rarely criticizes itself. Its fame stems in part from the fact that only about 13,000 copies were printed back in the '90s and the book has been out of print for years. Due to the scarcity, available copies of the most recent edition are going for as much as $350.
But while Mr. Doak's strong opinions resonate with golfers, they also have put him in somewhat of an awkward spot: Mr. Doak is now a high-profile part of the establishment he once unabashedly critiqued. And it's that reality that keeps him from reprinting or updating the sought-after book.
"I pulled no punches at all," Mr. Doak says in an interview. "I'm not sure I want to put myself in that position now."
Gary Polakovic of the LA Times looks at the Coastal Commission's plans to review the proposed new course at Pebble Beach and the political maneuvering for tonight's vote.
"This is one of the biggest disputes, one of the most significant issues since I've been on the Coastal Commission for 10-plus years," said Sara Wan, whose panel is charged with protecting the coast. "It ranks up there with the biggest controversies."
The more than $100-million Pebble Beach plan is also a potential environmental albatross for Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger, the Senate Rules Committee and Assembly Speaker Fabian Nuñez (D-Los Angeles), whose appointees each control four votes on the 12-member commission.
Thanks to reader John for this Conor Dougherty story in the Wall Street Journal, where the USGA continues to try desperately to shift the distance issue to a grooves debate:
Is the long debate over golf balls cooling off?
One day after the Masters Tournament last year, the U.S. Golf Association, golf's U.S. rule maker, sent a letter to ball manufacturers requesting prototypes of balls that wouldn't fly as far as those in use today. The announcement, which came amid claims by traditionalists including golfing legend Jack Nicklaus that longer drives on the PGA Tour were changing the game for the worse, sent waves through the industry.
The USGA emphasized it wanted only to get a better understanding of golf-ball technology, in case "the need to change the rules arises," but the move was viewed by some as a first step toward a dead-ball era.
Now the rhetoric from some of the most vocal traditionalists has softened, and the USGA says changing golf balls may not be the best solution to curbing longer drives. What happened?
Not sure which "vocal traditionalists" have gone quiet, judging by this site's listing of recent remarks from famous golfers calling on a rollback.
The USGA says its research has caused it to look beyond the golf ball. The issue may be not the changes in the golf ball, the association now says, but rather the way players have reacted to those changes.
Dick Rugge, the USGA's senior technical director, says pros have probably changed their style of play to accommodate newer golf balls that fly far but are also easy to control. In generations past, players had to make precise shots onto the fairway to win. Now they're increasingly trading accuracy for distance, hitting powerful drives that land in the rough more often and then hitting shorter irons to the green.
And...
These very visible changes, coupled with the new, sloppier style of play, angered traditionalists. Rather than lengthen golf courses each year, they argue, why not wind back the golf ball instead? "We've noticed that, in a lot of cases, [technology] makes our golf courses play quite a bit differently than they were intended when they were originally designed," says Alan Fadel, who is on the board of governors of the Ohio State Golf Association.
At its Champions Tournament in August, the association will issue a single kind of ball to all of the competitors, a high-spin model with a soft cover. This, in theory, should even the playing field for players with slower swing speeds. "It's more of a political statement than anything," Mr. Fadel says.
Dougherty recalls the 2002 Joint Statement of Principles, often forgotten these days in Far Hills:
In 2002, the USGA, which governs golf in the U.S. and Mexico, and Scotland's R&A, golf's ruling body for the rest of the world, said that if driving distances continued to increase they would consider changing the specifications for balls. Three years later, the USGA sent the letter asking manufacturers for prototype short balls.
Naturally, ball manufacturers oppose a rollback, and they argue that a change wouldn't be easy. Golf balls are built to an "overall distance standard" of 320 yards, which is defined as the maximum distance the ball will travel when hit by a titanium club, at 120 mph, under certain launch conditions. To change the standard, companies would have to fiddle with variables including the weight and size, as well as the cover and dimples, to change how the ball spins during flight.
"Then all iterations must be tested off the tee, as well as through the green, to confirm how the prototype is going to perform with all golfers and with all clubs in the bag under all conditions and types of shots to be faced," says Wally Uihlein, chief executive of Acushnet, based in Fairhaven, Mass.
Uh huh. Here's the part where somehow they think that changing groove specs will be less complicated and more important than a ball change:
The USGA has been busy researching hard data on the performance of golf balls. It crunched statistics on everything from the accuracy of drives on the PGA Tour to the correlation between accuracy and winning. The USGA made some discoveries that went against conventional wisdom -- and strengthened the case for keeping the balls as they were. The growth in driving distance, for instance, has tapered off in recent years. More important, distance alone doesn't help pros win. The longest hitters, the USGA found, do not win a disproportionate amount of tournaments, although they do win slightly more than in the past.
For now, the USGA is experimenting with new ways to penalize sloppy drives. For its U.S. Open Championships, the organization has traditionally had courses cut a narrow band of shorter rough along the fairway, and the rest of the rough -- called the primary rough -- cut to a uniform height of around three to five inches. But for this week's U.S. Open at Winged Foot Golf Club in Mamaroneck, N.Y., the USGA varied the primary rough: It will start with a 20-foot-wide band about three inches high; beyond that out to the spectator ropes, it will be at least five inches high. This deeper rough will hurt the least-accurate drivers the most, while rewarding cleaner play.
"We noticed that a shot that barely trickles into the rough has a similar penalty as a ball that goes 15 yards into the rough, and that just didn't seem fair to us," says Marty Parkes, a USGA spokesman. "We were trying to match the penalties with the crime."
And, just in case you weren't sure that these people have lost their golfing soul...
Another way to force golfers to be more accurate, Mr. Rugge says, would be to modify irons to make shots from the rough harder to control. The key to this is a series of small grooves on the face of irons: When the ball is struck from deep, wet grass, the grooves allow water trapped between the club and the ball to disperse, increasing the friction between club and ball and allowing a more controlled shot. Changing the guidelines to require smaller grooves would make for less friction, and more erratic shots, thus giving golfers more incentive to keep the ball in the fairway.And does this also mean that the message is: harvest more rough?
One advantage of a change in iron specifications would be that it would affect only those players who can shoot from the rough with pinpoint precision -- the top percent of golfers. And while the USGA suffered a contentious lawsuit about an iron change in the 1980s, it might be able to sidestep the issue by grandfathering in older-model irons.
Now that the NSA has figured out that my calls to Pakistan were all Dell support related, they've been feeding me all sorts of goodies. The latest is this Sunday night instant message exchange between the PGA Tour's Tim Finchem and the LPGA's Carolyn Bivens after the thrilling LPGA Championship finish.
twfPGATOUR©: You there Carolyn?
DaBrandLady: yes tim, just back from the trophy ceremony!
DaBrandLady: does these girls rock or what!?
DaBrandLady: and didn’t I look good next to Ronald McDonald!?!?!?! :)
twfPGATOUR©: Yes, great product today. What a shot by Se Ri.
twfPGATOUR©: Say, did you see any of the telecast?
DaBrandLady: just a bit when I was doing some brand positioning work in the McDonald’s chalet.
DaBrandLady: but we’ll be doing a full contextual and brand consistency white paper on the telecast this week to ensure that the brand promise was obtained. why do you ask?
twfPGATOUR©: I was wondering if there was a strike of the graphics personnel or other elements of the production staff?
twfPGATOUR©: Don’t get me wrong, the product was strong, but it just seemed to lack things like a leaderboard more than every 15 minutes or so.
DaBrandLady: that’s just Golf Channel’s effort to not interfere with our product.
DaBrandLady: the minimalist production values make each player on the screen the real focus of the viewer, adding value for our players and player sponsors.
twfPGATOUR©: I see.
DaBrandLady: well I think they accomplished what was called for within their business model in terms of graphics and production budget, but I’ll check with Deb, wait, no with…well I’m sure someone is left in the office to help out.
twfPGATOUR©: About that, I don’t know how you do it? I have 81 Vice Presidents and I can’t imagine what I’d do if I had mass resignations like you have had.
twfPGATOUR©: Not that there’s anything wrong with spending more time with your family and pursuing other opportunities.
DaBrandLady: no, nothing wrong at all.
DaBrandLady: look, given the LPGA's incredible mix of talent, diversity and personalities, now is the time to take this organization to new heights. While we change the business model in order to better monatize our success, fans can continue to expect the very best in women's professional golf. We're committed to collaborating with all of our key constituents to create a stronger LPGA.
twfPGATOUR©: Did you just copy and paste that from your press release?
DaBrandLady: oh tim, that’s why you are going to make $28.5 million over the next four years. nothing gets by you!
twfPGATOUR©: Well, thanks. Say, anything you can pass along about TGC’s production concepts would really help as we begin a 15-year journey with them.
twfPGATOUR©: Not that I’m concerned or anything, it’s just that well…I’m always looking out for my product.
DaBrandLady: as am i! that’s why you and me are so good at what we do!!!!!
twfPGATOUR©: Congrats again on the strong positioning today.
DaBrandLady: thanks you too…great job with vijay’s win today. he's a little out of the prime demo but a solid brand.
DaBrandLady: that reminds me, do you have a contact at the villages?
twfPGATOUR©: You're not planning to retire?
DaBrandLady: oh no, i'll be in this job for decades. i just wanted to talk to them about buying some time.
twfPGATOUR©: they’ve been good partners for us in this transition year.
DaBrandLady: i know, that’s why i want their number.
twfPGATOUR©: I’ll have someone look into that for you.
DaBrandLady: thanks! gotta run, tgc's replay of the trophy ceremony starts soon and there's a bar down the street that actually carries it!
twfPGATOUR©: Give my best to...
DaBrandLady: he says hi back! bye!
Doug Ferguson sums up Se Ri Pak's thrilling LPGA win, one of the most exciting tournaments in a long time despite The Golf Channel's minimalist production values. As tired as CBS's productions are these days, they are professionals and bring a level of production quality to their telecasts that this epic major deserved (and lacked).
It's a real shame for the LPGA "brand" that more people didn't get to see this and David Steele in the Baltimore Sun agreed in this column before Sunday's finale. As he points out, the LPGA could have been the prime network sporting event today (well, besides that soccer stuff).
New Yorker turned Angeleno Daniel Wexler remembers what he loves about Winged Foot in an L.A. Times "appreciation."
Richard Sandomir writes about the trend of online streaming and the USGA's plan to carry action from the 6th at 10th holes at USOpen.com. He also writes:
This will be the sixth year that the United States Golf Association will post streaming video from the Open. It did one hole the first year, and has done two holes ever since. This year, the group decided that Winged Foot's par-4 sixth hole, "the Pulpit," one of the course architect A. W. Tillinghast's masterpieces, was must-see viewing, as was the par-3 10th hole.
Of course No. 10 is definitely the "Pulpit" while No. 6 is actually "El" (as named by Tilly himself).
"I think the issue really isn't their theories or their ideas," said 2003 U.S. Open champion Jim Furyk. "It's how they handled it afterward. It's a real hard line. It's 'That's the way we wanted it to be. That's the way it should be.' When even the guys with 20-handicaps are scratching their heads. ... Only later on did they do damage control, but at that point, it was a little late."
Geoff Shackelford is a Senior Writer for Golfweek magazine, a weekly contributor to Golf Channel's Morning
Copyright © 2022, Geoff Shackelford. All rights reserved.