Shapiro Reviews Prospects For Washington Golf

The Washington Post's Leonard Shapiro on the PGA Tour pulling out of Washington:

I think the commissioner heard loud and clear that Washington was not about to accept a second-class golf event played at what has become a second-class venue at TPC Avenel. He heard it from his own players, from the press, from talk radio, from letters to the editor, from e-mails on the internet and other correspondence to his office in Ponte Vedra. And finally, I believe he got the point.

Now it seems as if the tour may also finally be getting serious about fixing up Avenel, ostensibly the reason there will be no tournament here in 2007, and probably 2008 as well. If the tour is going to spend what they say is $18 to $20 million and what others say likely will balloon to the $25 million range, they want to do it right.

They really can't re-route the golf course, but they can certainly move enough earth to make it a more challenging venue, and perhaps also upgrade the infrastructure Avenel never has had to support the thousands of golf fans who have flocked to the course year after year.

So does anyone know if these $20 and $25 million figures represent just what is being spent on the course, or also include a clubhouse redo?

Is The Open Really Open?

openlogo.jpgGolfweek's Alistair Tait makes some good points about the Open Championship qualifying, which is down to 12 spots after all of the exemptions.

Here are the recent qualifiers according to the R&A, with two spots remaining:

Qualifiers for The Open
 
Recent qualifiers for The Open through exemption categories 8, 15 and 16 and at Local Final Qualifying are: -
 
8. The leading player, not exempt, in the first 10 and ties of the 2006 Open de France, the 2006 Smurfit European Open and the 2006 Barclays Scottish Open. *
 
Marcus Fraser (Australia)
Anthony Wall (England)
 
15. First 2 USPGA Members and ties not exempt in a cumulative money list taken from the USPGA Tour Players Championship and the five USPGA Tour events leading up to the 2006 Western Open.
 
JJ Henry (USA)
Billy Andrade (USA)
 
16. The leading player not exempt having applied 15 in the first 10 and ties of the 2006 Buick Championship, the 2006 Western Open and the 2006 John Deere Classic. *
 
Hunter Mahan (USA)
Matthew Goggin (Australia)
 
 
* Still to be played

 
Local Final Qualifying
 
Conwy (Caernarvonshire)
Jon Bevan (Wessex Golf Centre)
Warren Bladon (Unattached)
Mikko Ilonen (Finland)
 
Formby
Jim Payne (Southport & Ainsdale)
Andrew Marshall (Unattached)
Darren Parris (North Foreland)
 
Wallasey
Danny Denison (A) (England)
Gary Day (Cookridge Hall)
Marcus Brier (Austria)
 
West Lancashire
Nick Ludwell (Selby)
Gary Lockerbie (Unattached)
Adam Frayne (St Mellion)

Ferguson: Blame Tiger and Phil

AP's Doug Ferguson says that Tim Finchem is not entirely to blame for the changes in Chicago and Washington D.C.

Finchem was a convenient target, the czar behind these changes aimed at making the golf season shorter and more interesting.

But it's not all his fault.

If anyone has complaints, look no further than Tiger Woods and Phil Mickelson. They were the catalysts who first started barking about the PGA Tour season being too long. All the commissioner did was respond to his two biggest stars.

Hawkins: Minus Criticism, FedEx Cup Gets No Ink

John Hawkins on his GolfDigest.com blog:

If not for a smattering of scathing criticism, last month’s “official” unveiling of the FedEx Cup format wouldn’t have gotten any attention whatsoever.
He goes on to write about Ed Sherman's recent blog post on markets the Tour is visiting and drops this Western Open stunner:
My sources tell me that Cialis, which picked up title sponsorship of the Western in 2004 after the tournament had struggled to find a successor to Advil, was eager to renew its commitment with the tour, even if it meant spending almost twice as much ($14 million) to subsidize a playoff event. Camp Ponte Vedra, however, was never crazy about aligning itself with a company that makes erectile-dysfunction pills. The tour basically told Cialis to take a hike, then courted BMW throughout the second half of 2005.

How can you turn away a major sponsor when so many other events are in need of them? Something just doesn't add up here. 

“I think they were probably bombarded"

Tod Leonard reports that the USGA has reversed it's decision on MacKinzie Kline, the 14-year-old whose doctors want her riding a cart in the U.S. Junior Girl's and U.S. Women's Amateur because of a heart condition.

USGA spokesman Marty Parkes said yesterday the ruling was made by the organization's three-person medical panel after receiving more documentation from the Klines last week.

“The more we looked into it, it was clear that because of her condition she needed a cart,” Parkes said.

“They stepped up and did the right thing,” said John Kline, MacKinzie's father. “They did more investigating rather than falling back just on what the rules were. They made the right decision.”

John Kline said he was deluged with e-mails and phone calls last week from supporters, many of them strangers, who vowed to contact the USGA to voice their displeasure.

“I think they were probably bombarded,” Kline said.

Of course, one wonders why they would have to be bombarded with emails and calls to figure this one out? And one wonders why one wonders about any bad USGA decision at this point?  

Bivens: "I do speak in complete sentences"

John Branch of the New York Times weighs in on the struggles of Carolyn Bivens. Nothing new here except for brilliance from the commissioner:

 “I really don’t have three heads, I don’t have an eye in the middle of my forehead, and I do speak in complete sentences,” Bivens, the L.P.G.A. commissioner, said in a telephone interview Friday from the organization’s headquarters in Daytona Beach, Fla.

Branch drops this mini-bombshell, but leaves it up to someone else to explore what the Brand Lady has in mind.

Even re-evaluating the majors is on her mind.

“If a fairy godmother dropped down tomorrow, what would be the criteria for a major?” Bivens said.

Thanks to readers Noonan and John for sending the link to this. 

Spontaneity

After Phil Mickelson's comments last week about knowing in advance what clubs he would be using off of tees, I tried to raise the question of whether this is a sign of the times, or a statement about course setup and design.

And as interesting as it was to read the Phil-hitting-driver-on-18-debate, I'm still curious what you think of the notion of "spontaneity" in course setup.

Is it a better test of a player's skill if they are forced to adapt to either via (A) weather conditions or (B) radical day-to-day changes in tee/hole location placement?

Obviously, by the leading nature of that question, I think we see true skill when players are asked to adapt and execute shots "on the spot."

When a player is made uncomfortable by an unexpected decision (as opposed to a 25-yard sliver of fairway), and overcomes that doubt to pull off a shot, again I think we find out who the better all-around player is.

So if they are asked to hit 3-iron on a hole for two days before surprisingly finding a tee up with a 7-iron the shot to a difficult hole location, it would seem that such a departure genuinely would tell us who can "hit all of the clubs in the bag."

Do you agree that spontaneity in course setup is a good thing, or would you view it as a form of trickery trying too hard to match the unpredictability of links golf (and that can only be created without a backlash by Mother Nature)?

IM'ing With The Commissioners II

Well my NSA sources have scored with another IM chat between Tim Finchem and Carolyn Bivens. As with the first of these IM exchanges obtained, the more recent chat provides a wonderful opportunity to better understand two of golf's most powerful leaders.

DaBrandLady: tim are you there?

twfPGATour©: Yes Carolyn. Hello.

DaBrandLady: how things?

twfPGATour©: Fine, though we hit a bit of a rough patch with some of the media reports lately on the 2007 platform shifts.

DaBrandLady: yeah i saw some of the brand hits you’ve taken. does the market research indicate any concerns?

twfPGATour©: No, all good there. Everyone is very pleased about our new alignment with BMW, the fans in particular are excited to interact with such a positive brand.
twfPGATour©: And all of my Vice Presidents are excited that they might get employee pricing on the new 7 series.

DaBrandLady: that’s wonderful. it's such a great brand.

DaBrandLady: and what about Washington D.C., we’re doing some benchmarking on a possible event there…

twfPGATour©: Solid demos, tricky permitting issues when you are trying to rebrand a golf course. Thomas Boswell is a bit of a pain, too.

DaBrandLady: speaking of rebranding, as part of the many exciting initiatives we are embarking on, i think we have something you will love

twfPGATour©: Oh?

DaBrandLady: i been reading that you love cooking

twfPGATour©:  Oh don’t believe everything Greg Norman and Sean Murphy say

DaBrandLady: not that kind of cooking silly! i meant food cooking, you know like on The Food Channel

twfPGATour©: Oh right, of course.

DaBrandLady: I was hoping you would buy some copies our new LPGA and Canyon Ranch branded cookbook

DaBrandLady: we’re leveraging the equity of both brands for charity!!!!!

twfPGATour©: That’s great Carolyn. Good for you. You know giving back is the heart of the PGA TOUR(C)
twfPGATour©: Just send a couple dozen copies over and I’ll give them out to policy boards for Christmas

DaBrandLady: oh, that's such an old demo, can’t you skew a little younger?

twfPGATour©: You know I’m always trying.

DaBrandLady: the pga tour should consider its own book cooking

DaBrandLady: I mean, book on cooking

twfPGATour©: You mean harnessing some of our young, athletic and young players?

DaBrandLady: like villegas! if i were you’d, I get him to the oscars after parties next year

twfPGATour©: Huh?

DaBrandLady: didn’t you hear about our oscars night branding?

twfPGATour©: Oh yes, yes, great idea, I’ll note that. Uh Carolyn, while I have you here...

DaBrandLady: Yes Tim?

twfPGATour©: These points standings and playoffs you have…

DaBrandLady: yes?

twfPGATour©: It’s connecting with the fans, right?

DaBrandLady: oh absolutely, you should see the hits we are getting on the desktop wallpaper download

twfPGATour©: Wallpaper?

DaBrandLady: yes, check it out:  LPGA Desktop Wallpaper

DaBrandLady: the 12-24 year olds love it. i use karrie webb in her nabisco robe for my computer desktop.

twfPGATour©: Oh I’ll check it out. Is there one for Brittany Lincicome?

DaBrandLady: oh tim, you identify with her can-do attitude, don’t you?

twfPGATour©: Yep, she’s a fighter. And I think I’m going to have to be one of this points thing doesn’t work out.

DaBrandLady: it’ll work out great tim, I know it. trust me, I have good instincts on these things

twfPGATour©: Thanks Carolyn, it’s reassuring to hear that from you.

DaBrandLady: anytime tim.

twfPGATour©: Well, goodnight Carolyn, give my best to…to...

DaBrandLady: he says hi back too! night!


Say Goodbye To Hamilton Farm...

...say hello to The Donald? Thanks to reader Tom for this Kevin Manahan story in the Star Ledger about the possible move of the recently concluded LPGA match play event (I don't the name and I'm too lazy to look it up).

 "This is a great course. I love this place," runner-up Juli Inkster said yesterday. "But it's probably not the best place for a match-play tournament. I'll be disappointed. It's a great golf course, and the people here have been wonderful, but it's probably not the perfect setting for an event like this."

Brittany Lincicome, the 39th seed, upset Inkster in the title match, 3&2. But the 20-year-old also ousted Michelle Wie, the 16-year-old phenom, and Lorena Ochoa, the LPGA Tour's leading money-winner this season. Inkster said people should have seen it coming. Lincicome is one of the longest hitters on the women's tour, and Hamilton Farm, with its wide-open fairways, lets the bombers swing fearlessly on the tee boxes.

"I didn't hit my driver well this week, and I think I missed one fairway," Inkster said. "If there are courses for horses, this place was made for Brittany. She has a tendency to get wayward with her driver on other courses, but here she could just bang away.

"For match play, you need a course that gives you more risk-reward situations. Give the long hitters a chance to go for the par 5s in two, but make them pay a price if they miss the shot. I love this place, but it's not the best place for match play."

With the two-year contract expired and a new deal unlikely, the tournament will have to find a new home. Marc Webster, the tournament director, had no comment yesterday on the future, but there is speculation the event could move to Trump National Bedminster, which is less than 10 miles away.

Trump officials have denied interest in the event, but that might have changed. Carolyn Kepcher, managing partner of Trump Golf Management and the chief operating officer of Trump National courses in Briarcliff Manor, N.Y., and Bedminster, was spotted at the pro-am on Wednesday, and people connected with the event said she was at the course "more than once."

LPGA Cookbook To Feature Bivens Recipe For Benchmarking

I'm teeing this one up for you, feel free to submit your recipe suggestions under "Comments."

GOOD LPGA EATS: LPGA Tour commissioner Carolyn Bivens and current and former players have combined with Canyon Ranch integrative wellness resorts on a 60-page cookbook: The LPGA Cooks with Canyon Ranch. Proceeds from the $10 US book will benefit Shape Up America!, a not for profit organization for raising awareness of obesity as a health issue.

Bivens submitted a recipe for beef lasagna.

Other recipes included Hall of Famer Nancy Lopez's turkey chili; Natalie Gulbis' healthy beef stew, Beth Daniels' Dijon chicken, Karrie Webb's avocado, mango and walnut salad, Ai Miyazato's Edamame rice balls and Morgan Pressel's championship bundt cake. Paula Creamer has recipes for raisin scones and chicken salad. Canyon Ranch chefs also provide new recipes.
 

MacDuff's Post Western FedEx Cup Points Standings

fedexcuplogo.jpgAs it stands now, the wonderful David Duval would get in the FedEx Cup playoffs if MacDuff's points system was used, but the future Ryder Cup captain (you can always dream David!) doesn't qualify using the Tour's system. I know you can hardly contain your shock over this development.

On a serious note. Really. I know "strength of field" is being taken into account in the Tour's version by giving extra points to the majors, THE PLAYERS and the WGC's. But that would seem to just increase the likelihood of big name players who are prone to play a light schedule, continuing to not play often enough.

While under MacDuff's system' each event would have more sway. Oh wait, this is all assuming that the playoffs are actually hard to get into. My bad!

1    Mickelson    22546.5        15
2    Singh    21859.37        16
3    Furyk    21312.5        14
4    Gf. Ogilvy    18487.5        12
5    Pettersson    18383.33        16
6    Glover    17241.66        13
7    Cink    17146.33        14
8    Immelman    17112.5        12
9    Weir    16659.37        14
10    Appleby    16437.5        13
11    Donald    16339.37        11
12    Toms    16196.87        11
13    Van Pelt    15940        17
14    A.Scott    15725        11
15    C.Campbell    15587.5        13
16    Pampling    15535        14
17    Pernice    15525        12
18    Z.Johnson    15362.5        13
19    B. Quigley    15075        12
20    Oberholser    14637.5        13
21    Bohn    14238.33        14
22    Verplank    14087.5        12
23    Gay    14037.5        14
24    Funk    14025        15
25    T.Clark    14010        13
26    Olazabal    13862.5        10
27    Sabbatini    13754.16        12
28    Mayfair    13679.16        15
29    Vn Taylor    13162.5        12
30    Choi    13125        13
31    Goosen    12937.5        10
32    Jerry Kelly    12600        11
33    T.Woods    12584.37        7
34    Senden    12562.5        12
35    Harrington    12450        10
36    Purdy    12375        12
37    Hoffman    12137.5        13
38    Love III    12050        12
39    Ames    12012.5        9
40    Imada    11667.5        13
41    JJ Henry    11662.5        10
42    Crane    11585        12
43    Watney    11535.71        13
44    Chopra    11479.5        13
45    Villegas    11475        12
46    J.Ogilvie    11468.21        12
47    Allenby    11262.5        10
48    Herron    11247.5        12
49    N.Green    11177.5        13
50    Flesch    11143.21        16
51    Els    11140        11
52    D.Wilson    11112.5        12
53    Lehman    11075        11
54    Warren    11075        12
55    Leonard    10820.83        12
56    Parnevik    10767.5        12
57    Sluman    10762.5        14
58    S. Maruyama    10550        11
59    Wetterich    10425        9
60    Stricker    10362.5        8
61    Rose    10329.16        12
62    RS Johnson    10305        10
63    Bryant    10257        10
64    Slocum    10187.5        12
65    Austin    10150        14
66    Poulter    10062.5        10
67    Curtis    9762.5        12
68    F.Jacobson    9675        10
69    Branshaw    9662.5        10
70    D. Howell    9587.5        8
71    Palmer    9466.66        11
72    Bertsch    9431.25        13
73    Jobe    9392.5        11
74    Kenny Perry    9375        11
75    Br.Davis    9342.5        11
76    Beem    9318.75        11
77    Lonard    9298.21        12
78    Howell III    9187.5        14
79    Hart    9167.5        10
80    Garcia    9112.5        8
81    Waldorf    9087.5        11
82    Micheel    9075        10
83    Lowery    9062.5        11
84    JB Holmes    8945.83        9
85    Estes    8925        10
86    Sean O'Hair    8824.5        11
87    Maggert    8812.5        9
88    G. Owen    8662.5        9
89    Barlow    8612.5        11
90    Goggin    8600.25        7
91    Azinger    8562.5        11
92    Rollins    8537.5        9
93    Andrade    8482.5        10
94    Couples    8437.5        10
95    Baird    8242.5        8
96    Pavin    8200        8
97    Mahan    8187.5        12
98    Gove    8175        8
99    Franco    8112.5        9
100    Sutherland    8075        11
101    DiMarco    7959.37        9
102    Gronberg    7937.5        9
103    Kaye    7900        11
104    Olin Browne    7812.5        13
105    J.Smith    7800        10
106    Sindelar    7787.5        12
107    Cook    7700        8
108    Calcavecchia    7617.5        14
109    Geiberger    7481.25        11
110    Leaney    7437.5        8
T111    Dickerson    7325        10
T111    Fischer    7325        10
113    Triplett    7175        8
114    Faxon    7125        10
115    O'Hern    7100        5
116    Langer    7079.16        9
117    Gore    7050        7
118    Lickliter II    7050        9
119    Bjornstad    7030        10
120    Baddeley    6962.5        8
121    B. Haas    6962.5        9
122    JL Lewis    6937.5        11
123    M.Wilson    6902.5        8
124    J.Byrd    6862.5        5
125    Bub Watson    6850        7
126    Barron    6606.25        9
127    Armour III    6425        8
128    Pat Perez    6350        8
129    Durant    6281.25        13
130    Cabrera    6162.5        6
131    Allen    6050        9
132    Gamez    5962.5        10
133    Overton    5887.5        11
134    Ridings    5737.5        10
135    D.Maruyama    5687.5        9
136    Atwal    5650        6
137    David Duval    5525        7
138    Garrigus    5505        9
139    Ws Short Jr    5462.5        11
140    Frazar    5375        8
141    D.Clarke    5275        5
142    Matteson    5225        9
143    Westwood    5187.5        5
144    Petrovic    5187.5        8